Chapter 8 | Bondage to the Law

Chapter 5 | Hour of Need

Chapter 4 | Cemetery for the Living Man

Jun 24, 202630 minSummary

In this episode of Bone Valley, the narrative shifts to Anthony DiPippo’s harrowing transition into the New York state prison system following his conviction for the murder of Josette Wright. Anthony recounts the dehumanizing process of being processed at Downstate Correctional before being moved to the maximum-security prison at Shawangunk. He details a life defined by constant fear, violent survival, and the strategic alliances he formed—including securing protection from influential incarcerated figures—to endure the environment. As Anthony begins to adapt, he adopts the role of a jailhouse lawyer, fueled by a rigorous self-taught education in law and a desperate need for exoneration. The episode highlights his obsessive investigation into his own case files, where he discovers long-buried inconsistencies and witness statements that the original detectives seemingly ignored or suppressed. By meticulously analyzing these documents, Anthony uncovers significant evidence pointing toward Howard Gombert, a man who possessed the exact vehicle described by witnesses and had a documented history of violence. This chapter underscores Anthony’s transformation from a young, vulnerable inmate to a determined, calculated researcher fighting to expose the truth behind his wrongful conviction.

Chapter 3 | A Knife in the Heart of My Freedom

Jun 17, 202643 minSummary

In this episode of Bone Valley, the focus shifts to the harrowing experiences of Anthony DePippo and Andy Krevak, who find themselves imprisoned for a crime they adamantly deny committing: the rape and murder of twelve-year-old Josette Wright. The narrative highlights the systemic corruption and coercive tactics employed by the Putnam County Sheriff’s Office, specifically investigators Castaldo and Quick. The episode details how Andy Krevak was manipulated into signing a false nine-page confession after hours of intense interrogation without legal counsel. Meanwhile, Anthony DePippo faces his own nightmare, struggling to maintain his innocence while witnessing his best friend succumb to police pressure. A pivotal development occurs when a key witness, Dominic Neglia, admits to having been coerced into providing false testimony against them. However, the trial judge’s refusal to allow Neglia to testify in court proves to be a devastating blow to Anthony's defense. The episode meticulously exposes the investigators' lack of training, their failure to document interviews, and their disregard for legal standards like the Brady rule, painting a damning picture of a murder investigation built entirely on fabricated evidence and coerced statements.

Chapter 2 | Ride or Die

Jun 10, 202631 minSummary

In the second episode of Bone Valley, titled Chapter 2 | Ride or Die, the narrative delves into the complex history and unraveling lives of Anthony and his best friend, Andy Kreevak. Following a 1995 drug bust involving PCP, the two young men find themselves caught in a mounting legal nightmare that transcends simple narcotics possession. As the investigation into the death of young Josette Wright intensifies, the Putnam County detectives shift their focus toward the pair, employing aggressive interrogation tactics and accusations to pressure them. The episode explores the deep, lifelong bond between Anthony and Andy, tracing their shared struggles with broken family dynamics and their attempt to forge their own paths through wrestling fantasies and reckless behavior. Tension builds as Anthony begins to suspect that his acquaintances and even his closest confidant may be turning against him. The episode culminates in a shocking legal development when Anthony, having sought a brief stint in jail to reset his life, is suddenly charged with the murder of a child, discovering that his ride-or-die companion has seemingly implicated him in the crime.

Chapter 1 | Criminal Mischief

Jun 10, 202631 minSummary

In the premiere episode of Bone Valley, titled Chapter 1 | Criminal Mischief, host Paul Solatarov explores the haunting 1995 disappearance and murder of twelve-year-old Josette Wright in Carmel, New York. The episode opens with a chilling discovery: two hunters, Peter Erksson and his friend Bruce, stumble upon skeletal remains in the woods of Putnam County, later identified as the missing girl. Solatarov, a veteran journalist, meticulously reconstructs the atmosphere of the small, seemingly quiet town during the mid-nineties. Through interviews with those who knew Josette—including a former resident of a local group home—the episode paints a portrait of a vulnerable young girl struggling to find belonging in an unstable home environment. The narrative also introduces Anthony, a teenager often dismissed by local law enforcement as a "thug" due to his appearance and drug-related activities. The episode highlights the questionable tactics of investigators like Detective Pat Castaldo, who fixated on local outcasts rather than conducting a thorough search for the true perpetrator. Ultimately, the story sets the stage for a decades-long investigation into a murder that remains a source of lingering dread.

Introducing - Bone Valley Season 5 | The Devil's Quarry

Jun 3, 20263 minSummary

In this introductory episode of Bone Valley Season 5, titled The Devil’s Quarry, journalist Gilbert King returns to investigate a haunting and complex criminal case. The narrative centers on the brutal murder of a young child, a tragedy that left investigators and the community shaken by the perpetrator’s lack of remorse and unsettling demeanor. King delves into the chilling history of the primary suspect, Anthony DiPippo, uncovering a disturbing pattern of previous violence that suggests a far deeper and more sinister trajectory than initially realized. Through harrowing testimony and careful examination of the evidence, the episode explores the terror of the victims and the lingering trauma that persists long after the sentencing. King, known for his relentless pursuit of justice in systemic and high-stakes cases, confesses that this particular investigation has challenged his professional objectivity and emotional resilience. By connecting the dots between disparate crimes and the persistent whispers of a malevolent presence in the woods, the episode sets the stage for a dark exploration of evil. The listener is invited to confront a reality where the devil is not a metaphor, but a tangible threat hiding in plain sight.

Gilbert King Presents: Bone Valley Season 5 | The Devil's Quarry

May 28, 202637 minSummary

In the fifth season of the podcast Bone Valley, titled The Devil's Quarry, journalist Paul Solitarov and editor Liz Garber explore a disturbing case of systemic corruption and institutional misconduct in Putnam County, New York. Solitarov, a veteran reporter known for his pursuit of justice for the marginalized, brings his deep experience investigating the American carceral state to this project. The season focuses on the wrongful conviction of two young men and the broader, harrowing culture of a law enforcement agency that allegedly preyed upon vulnerable teenagers. The discussion highlights the challenges of balancing narrative storytelling with the grim realities of trauma and sexual violence. Garber emphasizes the rigorous fact-checking process required to untangle decades of local legend from legal fact. Throughout the episodes, the podcast moves beyond mere true crime to examine the long-term emotional wreckage left in the wake of systemic failure. By centering the voices of survivors and those wrongfully accused, the series serves as a powerful call for accountability, aiming to address injustices that have remained hidden for years. This season represents a significant effort to expose deep-seated corruption while seeking truth and healing for the victims involved.

Introducing: My Mother's Lies

Apr 9, 20269 minSummary

In this episode of Bone Valley, listeners are introduced to the unsettling story of My Mother's Lies. The narrative begins in the summer of 2000, when Jessica Currin was discovered murdered in a small Kentucky town. Susan Galbreath played a pivotal role in the subsequent investigation, ultimately helping law enforcement secure a life sentence for Quincy Cross. However, years later, Susan’s son, Ray McCord, discovers a box of his mother’s private files that shatters his understanding of the case. As Ray examines the handwritten notes, letters, and photographs left behind, he uncovers inconsistencies that suggest a dark deception. This episode follows Ray’s journey as he begins to question everything he knew about his mother’s involvement in the crime, setting the stage for a gripping investigation into the truth behind a decades-old conviction.

Introducing - Blood Will Tell

Mar 19, 202610 minSummary

In this special preview episode, the creators of Bone Valley introduce the compelling new series Blood Will Tell. The narrative centers on a shocking incident in suburban San Jose, where a birthday party ends in tragedy and a lethal confrontation. When police identify eighteen-year-old identical twins Trung and Anh as suspects, a case of mistaken identity leads to a harrowing miscarriage of justice. One brother spends two years behind bars for a crime he did not commit, raising profound questions about loyalty, sacrifice, and the unbreakable bond of family. Listeners will follow the complex, Shakespearean saga of these Vietnamese-American brothers as they grapple with silence and an unthinkable choice that alters their lives forever. This episode sets the stage for a gripping investigation into how the authorities could make such a devastating error and what ultimately drives one brother to accept another's burden.

Chapter 7 | Messy

Feb 4, 202638 minSummary

In this installment of Bone Valley, the investigation into the conviction of Toforest Johnson takes a sharp turn as the narrative shifts toward the credibility of key witnesses. Host Beth Shelburne explores the mounting doubts surrounding Violet Ellison, whose shifting accounts and history within the legal system raise serious red flags. Even the original prosecutor, Jeff Wallace, begins to grapple with the possibility that the state's case was built on a foundation of deception rather than truth. Listeners will follow as the podcast dissects Ellison’s complex background, painting a portrait of a figure whose actions were far more calculating than the prosecution ever admitted. This chapter peels back the layers of a flawed trial, highlighting the systemic failures that allowed a questionable narrative to dismantle a man's life. It is a compelling look at the messy reality behind a decades-old injustice.