Trial Verdict and Sentencing

We'll get back to your true crime story in just a moment This podcast is part of the always True Cime netwk home of thousands of episodes exploring gripping true crime cases If you're looking for somewhere to start, check out our recent investigative series, Project Mind Control It uncovers a chilling chapter in history, examining the disturbing experiments carried out on vulnerable people in an attempt to erase and reprogram the human mind featuring testimony from one of the last known survivors of a notorious Canadian psychiatric institution powerful story that's as shocking as it is important. Check out the show and more at alwaysTrue crime. com One day AI agents took over my work Absolutely love Chasing deadlines, writing status reports, updating stakeholders, agents handle the daily grind now. They live inside Monday dot comot so they see the full picture, My work, my team, the whole company. And I don't have to worry about the data. It's safe, whichich means I'm free to focus on the big stuff, knowing everything runs smoothly in the background. It's completely shifted the way we work Create your own AI agent in mininutes on Monday. com Better Hel A Hold on. One second I just need to What if you had a room where no one interrupts No notifications, no expectations J space to talk. Better Hel, theraapy happens in a space that's yours. Visit betterhLp. com slash random podcast for ten percent off your first month of online therapy ACAS powers the world's best podcasts. Here's a show that we recommend. Go touch grass. You have probably heard this phrase. Mbe you have even said it, but beneath the sort of lighthearted nature of this meme is something very real and important a growing sense that staying in touch with our humanity and being present in our bodies Matters more than ever in today's digital world. My name is Manushh Zamarodi, and I am taking over as host of Ted Talks Daily this week to explore what technology is actually doing to your body and mind In special interviews with scientists, doctors, parents, artists, and more, we're going to dig into your physical and mental health on tech we think about our bodies differently now, how we relate to new innovations that are amazing, but also a little scary, and how we can live a healthier life in this high tech era. Tune in on TED Talks Daily, wherever you listen to podcasts ACast helps creators launch, grow, and monetize their podcasts everywhere AS. com In december two thousand nine, a fifty seven year old woman was settling into what should have been the happiest chapter of her life After years of hard work, Melinda Palmer had retired to a quiet countryside village in Worcestershire with a husband of twenty six years People had recently bought an isolated detached house, surrounded by fields and woodland and we're making plans for the future together. to neighbours and friends, they seem devoted to one another comfortable and content. But just days before Christmas, the image of their perfect marriage shattered completely Jonathan Palmer claimed he had returned home to find his wife brutally murdered at the bottom of the stairs after an apparent burglary gone wrong Yet almost immediately, detectives began to suspect something wasn't right As forensic experts examined the scene, they uncovered evidence suggesting the burglary had been staged. And as investigators dug deeper, they discovered a web of lies, secret mobile phones, online affairs, fake identities, and a double life hidden behind the image of a devoted husband In this episode of British Murders withith Stuart Blues, we're discussing the murder of Melinda Palmer. It's a case involving betrayal, deception, and a violent outburst that destroyed an entire life in a single afternoon. It's the story of a woman who spent years building a future with the man she trusted most only to be killed by him. when his secret life finally came crashing down around him Before we start just a quick reminder to follow the podcast, it's completely free and one of the best ways to support the show You could leave the rating or review that helps enormously as well, and if you want ad free listening, early access and exclusive episodes, head over to patreon. com forward slash Britishmurders to join my ever growing community. Melinda Mary Palmer was fifty seven years old during this story's main timeline and had grown up in Putneet, southwest London, alongside two brothers and her sister, Penelope, who most people knew as Penny Melinda was bright, driven and ambitious from a young age and excelled at school, eventually going on to earn herself a degree at Sheffield University It was during the early nineteen eighties that she met Jonathan David Palmer, better known as John, he's the other primary person involved in this story And honestly, the way they met sounded like something out of a cheesy Rom com. They were in a nightclub in nineteen eighty when Palmer started chatting Melinda up aking jokes and trying his luck At one point a bouncer apparently came over to Melinda and asked if this guy was bothering her. Her response involved her smiling before saying No Actually, I think he's cute. It seemed to be a match made in heaven A real love at first sight kind of thing And three years later, in nineteen eighty three, their relationship was taken to the next level when they got married Now from the outside looking in, they seemed like a loving couple who were devoted to each other They never had children, but it wasn't through a lack of trying. Melinda even underwent IVF treatment and at one stage did become pregnant But heartbreakingly, she suffered a miscarriage. Close to her said she threw herself into a career after that. And she did so excellently Melinda climbed the management ladder through roles at TransCO National Grid before eventually working in middle management for British Gas. colloeagues described her as warm, compassionate and level headed. Somebody with a brilliant smile and a just get on with an attitude to life Even during heated meetings at work, people said she had this calming presence about her. She could stey a room without making a song and dance about it. which was undoubtedly a welcome trait Parmer, on the other hand, was almost the polar opposite to his wife Over the years he'd worked as a miner, a salesman, and later took on a part time role as a debt collector The people who knew the couple often got the impression Melinda was the one driving things forward in life. She was the bread winner earning all the money So therefore handle the finances and organized things. Palmer, by comparison, simply enjoyed spending said money on frivolous stuff He enjoyed gadgets, expensive mobile phones and flashy cars The couple even owned a Teshare property in Portugal. But while Melinda had ambition and direction, Palmer seemed happy drifting through life without much interest in anything beyond tele, beer and his computer According to Penny, debating with him was almost impossible because his views were so black and white He wasn't well read, nor did he care much for current affairs or exercise. I do say that opposites attrack, and it was certainly ringing true for the Palmers Even so For years, the marriage appeared to be a solid one The couple spent two years living in Sheffield, South Yorkshire before moving down to Knoll near Sollyhole in the West Midlands At one point, they both gave up work to help care for Melinda's elderly parents, even buying a property specifically for the arrangement But it didn't last long Apparently, there was a personality clash involving Palmer And after about a year, Lelinda's parents moved into a nursing home instead The house tied to that care plan ended up being sold for roughly half a million pounds And around the same time Melinda secured herself a seventy thousand pound redundancy package alongside a solid pension So financially, they were definitely comfortable In may two thousand nine, the Palmers decided to begin what should have been the peaceful retirement chapter of their lives, their twilight years They bought a detached house called Windy Ridge on Crab Lane in the village of Wadborough for three hundred grand, which when adjusted for inflation is around four hundred eighty seven grand today Woodborough is a tiny village, proper countryside territory We're talking a population of five hundred or so and it's located five miles east of Worcester Think narrow lanes, open fields, woodland, old cottages The sort of place where life moves slowly and everybody notices when somebody new arrives One of the best known buildings there is Staint Giles' Church, parts of which date all the way back to the twelfth century. So this village had historyory running through it long before the palmers ever turned up. And Windy Ridge itself was incredibly isolated. pull it rural, way out in the sticks Only a handful of houses sat along Crab Lane, surrounded by countryside in every direction If you stood outside at night, you'd hear little more than the wind, the odd passing car and whatever wildlife happened to be nearby For Melinda and Palmmer though Perfect Absolutely love the place plans to renovate it, including converting the garage into a new kitchen And according to people who met them around that time, they seemed genuinely excited about their shared future The woman they bought the property from even became friends with them afterwards She later said they came across as quiet and pleasant and she never saw any animosity between them whatsoever That seemed to be the common theme from everybody The landlord at the village pub, the Mason's Ams, which is around a mile from Windy Ridge on station Road right in the heart of the village Rembember the couple coming in occasionally for lunch Usually it was just the two of them sharing a baguette and keeping themselves to themselves. He said they always seem perfectly nice together. Penny said much of the same. There were no problems between them, and this seemed totally compatible, she said He looked after her and they appeared to be very much in love Penny had emigrated to Canada by this stage, but she came back to the UK for a holiday in september two thousand nine and visited the couple at Windy Ridge Most of their conversations revolved around the house and all the plans they had for it deceorating, renovations, the usual retirement life stuff Pennet later admitted their lives had become very dull and boring But she accepted Palmer Because in her eyes, he made a sister happy And that's important to note because there were no screaming rows anybody knew about reports of domestic abuse or public cracks in the marriage to everybody around them, they were just a middle aged couple quietly settling into retirement in the gorgeous Worcestershire countryside But behind that calm exterior Palmer had developed some habits that painted a slightly different picture Most nights he stayed awake until around two AM, drinking six to eight cans of beer while watching TV or sitting on his computer for hours And before long, that computer would completely change everything On december nineteenth, two thousand nine, just days before Christmas The woman who'd sold them Windy Ridge invited the Palmers over for festive drinks alongside some of the neighbourors The night went well And again, nobody noticed anything unusual People were relaxed and seemed content in each other's company, looking ahead to the rest of the festive season But within days, Melinda Dead Tuesday december twenty second, two thousand nine began like any other winter day in rural Worcestershire. It was bitterly cold throughout the UK at the time And by that evening, Windy Ridge would become the center of a murder investigation that would horrify the quiet village of Woodborough foreverm eight twenty seven PM Pet dial nine nine nine And on that call, he reportedly sounded panicked He told the operator he'd come home to find what looked like a burglary and discovered his wife Melinda, lying dead at the bottom of the stairs There was blood everywhere And according to Palmer, someone had broken into the isolated countryside home while he'd been away and killed his wife That night, husband and wife police officers Ken and Linda Hawkins were on mobile patrol through Pershore High Street when the emergency call came through And when I said it were freezing that night just a moment ago, I wasn't exaggerating From december seventeenth, two thousand nine to january fifteenth, twenty ten. The UK experienced a spell of very low temperatures and significant snowfalls, which affected almost the whole country It was actually the most widespread and prolonged spell of such weather since late nineteen eighty one and early nineteen eighty two Large areas of England, Wales and Northern Ireland regularly saw nighttime temperatures falling well below freezing And on one occasion below minus ten Celsius, which is about fourteen Fahrenheit It was so cold that night that the blue flashing light on the patrol car actually froze over due to the low temperatures Just before midnight, the officers arrived at Windy Ridge to find the property stood lit up in the darkness. And inside the lounge sat Palmer. ing a phone and appearing distraught PC Linda Hawkins headed further into the house and quickly found Melinda, whose body lay at the foot of the stairs in the hallway She'd already passed away by the time they arrived, as confirmed by her having no pulse Back of Melinda's head was covered in mattered blood and her body already felt cold to the touch. So straight away, the officers got the impression she'd been dead for quite some time Dried blood could be seen in the hallway. And it was obvious to the officers that Melinda hadn't died recently Nearby drawers had been pulled out and parts of the house appeared ransacked PC Linda radioed back to base with her initial thoughts that this could have been a burglary gone wrong PC Ken stayed with Palmer He later described Palmer as being very distressed and recalled him crying Despite the scene inside the house, suspicion began falling on Palmer remarkably quickly A senior officer arrived at the scene soon after PC Linda funded it in and immediately decided something wasn't right For one thing, Palmer's appearance raised eyebrows Despite supposedly discovering his brutally murdered wife and being surrounded by blood He was only wearing a t shirt and trousers and officers couldn't find a single trace of the red stuff on any of his clothing With that, Palmer was arrested at the scene on suspicion of murder. Aarently, he seemed genuinely shocked by the decision. As officers took him into custody, he repeatedly called them horrible for arresting him Now, obviously, people react to trauma differently So on its own, that means very little But investigators were already beginning to look beyond the burglary story Police surgeon Dr. Kelvin Laidlaw later examined Palmer and noticed slight injuries to two fingers on his right hand. Palmer insisted those injuries had happened either while leaving the house or during the journey to the police station Pors weren't convinced though The deeper they dug, the shakier Palmer's version of events became. Melinda had not simply died during a burglary gone badly wrong She'd been battered to death, causing severe injuries to her head whoever killed her had used significant force While research in this case, I actually came across something quite eerie online There's an in Memorium tribute apparently written by Palmer himself, which was posted on the very day Melinda died. It read Taken from me twenty second, december two thousand nine cried a million tears and I'll cry a million more until I'm with you again I won't say goodbye I'll never stop loving you You are my wife my world, my rock and my best friend broken husband. John Honestly, reading that knowing what we know now is chilling Because while he was presenting himself as this devastated husband whose entire world had collapsed, es were already building a case against him. We're going to take a break here. When we return, we'll discuss the police investigation which eventually led to Palmer being convicted of murder. See you soon This Monday. com ad was created by a team of people and AI agents. The agents wrote the copy and managed the timelines, while our human creative director made sure it all made sense. Easy Create your own AI agent today on Monday. com Better help add. Hold on. One second I just need to. What if you had a room where no one interrupts No notifications, no expectations J just space to talk. Better Hel, theraapy happens in a space that's yours. Visit betteretterhLp. com slash random podcast for ten percent off your first month of online therapy Quick question, when was the last time a display ad changed your mind Now think about the last time a friend told you about something they loved. Different feeling, right? That's how podcast advertising works A host who's built real trust with their audience talks about your brand in their own words in their own voice. It doesn't interrupt the experience. It's part of it. With ACAast, you can access the world's largest podcast marketplace. Choose the right shows, the right audiences, the right format. thenen watch the data tell you it worked. You're not buying impressions You're buying influence Learn more by visiting acast d. com slash advertise Welcome back. Let's now carry on with the rest of the story Two days after Christmas, it was publicly confirmed that Palmer had been charged with his wife's murder, after a postmortem examination carried out on Christmas Eve had revealed the extent of Melinda's head injuries, confirming this had been an incredibly violent killing Investigators were now focusing on something else entirely Palmer's movements on the day of the murder This is where the case started becoming far more calculated than a panicked husband stumbling across a crime scene. West Merciire Police issued a major appeal covering Worcestershire, Derbyshire, Leicestershire, and Nottinghamshire. becausecause detectives believe Palmer had traveled through all four counties on the day Melinda died They wanted sightings of his highly distinctive gold colored land Rover Dcovery landmark TD five with the registration L twenty two JDP According to investigators, the vehicle had traveled from Worksop in Nottinghamshire sometime between five thirty PM and the moment Palmer dialed nine hundred ninety nine at eight hundred twenty seven PM and police suspected he hadn't simply been driving around aimlessly. They believe they may have stopped at motorway junctions, service stations and laybys along routes including the M five, M forty two, A forty two and M one Motorway CCTV appeared to support the allegation that Palmer had left the house after his wife had already been killed Even more suspiciously, detectives appealed for anybody who may have seen the landdver parked up while the driver disposed of black binliners which immediately paints a grim picture, doesn't it Police also traced the vehicle to places including Evessham, Fst Park near Leicester, and a Sainsbury supermarket in workshops. At the same time, officers work to identify anybody who may have been near Windy Ridge between one minute past midnight and half past eight that evening becausecause by now, detectives were becoming increasingly certain there'd be no mystery burglar at all This had all the signs of a staged scene Over the following months, Palmer appeared at several court hearings as the case slowly moved towards trial And when proceedings finally began at Worcester Crown Court in august twenty ten before Judge Robert Jukes QC The full picture of Palmer's secret life started to emerge Such secrets included a web of infidelities that completely shattered the image of the quiet, devoted, grieving husband everyone thought they knew He really left no stone unturned The affairs were one thing But he also used fake identities, kept a burner phone A made up stories about who he was, where he lived, and what he did for work Prosecutor Stephven Linhan QC told the jury that Palmer had killed Melinda during what was likely a sudden explosion of rage rather than a carefully planned murder According to the prosecution, Melinda had discovered evidence of her husband's affairs through a secret mobile phone he'd been using behind her back Linahan alleged that Palmer then used a heavy object to repeatedly strike his wife, causing devastating injuries to her skull The fractures were so severe that they penetrated her brain It was such a brutal attack And prosecutors believe Melinda had even tried desperately to reach her phone and call nine hundred and ninety nine as her towering six foot five husband attacked her Afterwards, rather than call for help, Palmer began trying to cover his tracks, including stage in the burglary scene. drawers cupboards had been pulled open around the house to create the impression that intruders had broken in But investigators quickly spotted problems with that theory For starters, a burglar wouldn't have had a reason to carefully arrange Melinda's body after killing her Prosecutors said that's exactly what had happened Linahan told the jury her body had clearly been moved. And in fact, detectives believe Palmer initially hid Melinda's body elsewhere in the house while he went out for the day likely to avoid it being discovered by any potential unexpected visitors Then, later before calling police, he moved her to the front hall near the staircase to fit the burglary store he was peddling There was also another chilling detail laid out in court. Whoever moved Melinda's body had apparently wrapped cling film around her head to prevent blood trailing through the house. Because fragments of the stuff, which is also known as Saran wrap were found on her body. Investigators later discovered the material matched King film from the same role as a piece covering chicken inside the Palmer's fridge But when police search Windy Ridge, the actual role itself had vanished justust like the suspected murder weapon Itated mysteriously and conveniently Plus, although the house appeared ransacked, some things hadn't been touched at all including a jewelry collection worth around four thousand pounds which obviously made little sense if this was supposed to be a burglary Why would a robber leave valuable jewelry behind prorosecution's answer was simple. because there had never been a burglar in the first place Palmer denied murder in his wife. He pleaded not guilty and told jurors he'd spent part of that day getting the Christmas decorations down from the attic before kissing Melinda goodbye sometime between eleven thirty AM and twelve thirty PM He also claimed he had no idea what had happened to the Klingfilm roll, which was normally kept in a kitchen drawer When police searched the house, they collected all of Palmer's footwear because another item that miraculously disappeared was a pair of trainers which detectives became very interested in after they'd appeared in photographs of Palmer found inside the house. The missing pair was said to be dark Aidash triners with the patented three white stripes Andrew Greg, a footwear expert, told the court he examined impressions recovered from the murder scene and found eleven marks consistent with Adidas Samba or Samba super trainers The estimated shoe size from those prints was between a ten and twelve Pa or a size eleven Greg also ruled out ten other shoe manufacturers with similar sole patterns The prosecution believed Palmer had disposed of them because they were stained with Melinda's blood prosecution also claimed Palmer had disposed of far more than just shoes that day Because only hours after killing his wife, he drove across the country to visit another woman called Jackie And this part of this story feels so surreal. While Melinda lay dead back at Windy Ridge, Palmer traveled to Workshop to meet his lover for a Christmas shopping trip Beacky worked in a pub at the time and had first met Palmer online using his computer aroundround june two thousand nine through an internet game insight Within six weeks, he was regularly visiting her home Usually on Thursdays while her eleven year old daughter was at school during those secret meetings that they had sex While back at home, Melinda had been told her husband was out playing snooker at a club in Leicester where he'd grown up Jacky told the court, Palmer claimed he was comfortably off financially and didn't need to work anymore The pair even looked through property broushches together for houses worth up to four hundred and fifty grand Palmer spoke about them moving in together spending Christmas together and their future He said he'd made enough money and didn't need to work anymore, Jackie told the court Like everything else in Palmer's life, much of it was complete fantasy. At first, he told Jacket he lived alone while renovating a house in Leicester Later, it changed the story and claimed he shared the property with an ex girlfriend who refused to leave. At another point, he even lied that his long term partner had died in a traffic collision And over time, the messages between the two became intensely sexual Jackie told the jury We got very close and seemed to hit it off Detective Constable James Gordon later analyzed a memory card recovered from Palmer's mobile phone On it were downloaded pornographic images of Jackie alongside photographs of Palmer and Windy Ridge. Jackie also described the presents Palmer bought for her and her family in the run up to Christmas We're talking perfume, a handbag, computer games, clothes, even a coffee grinder He'd also spent more than two hundred and thirty pounds in cash on a supermarket food shop And that use of cash stood out as a red flag immediately to investigators According to the prosecution, Palmer had taken three hundred pounds from the house after murdering Melinda and used it during his shopping trip with Jacka Normally, he'd use credit cards instead of cash, something backed up by his bank statements Police discovered he hadn't withdrawn any cash from his own account two years On the morning Melinda was killed, Palmer sent Jacket a text message, saying Good morning, Angel. I love you. He also mentioned leaving a change of clothes at her house in preparation for Christmas Day Let expected him to arrive between nine and ten AM on december twenty second, so they could start shopping early. but he instead turned up at around three PM his explanation claimed his ex girlfriend had committed suicide They he'd spend hours helping the police deal with it The real reason was far darker. cution alleged Palmmerers spent those missing five or six hours Hiding evidence, moving Melinda's bodyet and fixing his alibi before driving to Workshop. Jackkey later remembered seeing binliners inside the boot of his landver when he finally arrived O believe those bags may have contained his bloodstained clothes and possibly the murder weapon itself, which has never been recovered At some point during his journey with Jackie, Palmer started destroying his phone inside the car before throwing it from the window while driving on a motorway but it didn't destroy it sufficiently And as a result, detectives retrieved those sexual images as well as numerous messages between him and Jackie. including one where Palmer wrote I adore you We'll be together after Christmas. Then we can plan what to do with our lives I'll never stop loving you. Except Jackie wasn't the only woman Palmer had been deceiving The jury also heard about another affair with a woman called Beverlet from near Southampton That relationship had lasted around two years, and again had started online while Palmer was supposedly helping care for Melinda's family members.