True Crime Stories Podcasts

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

Exactly Right and iHeartPodcasts

My Favorite Murder, hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark, invites listeners into a space where true crime curiosity meets genuine human connection. Far more than a standard investigative series, this show thrives on the chemistry between two lifelong friends who balance the grim realities of dark history with sharp wit and heartfelt personal reflection. Whether they are diving into the complex archives of a colonial-era murder, analyzing the psychological unraveling of high-profile cases, or exploring the surreal narratives of historical charlatans, their storytelling is always grounded in deep empathy and a commitment to understanding the human condition. The podcast is structured around a mix of long-form, meticulously researched deep dives and the wildly popular Minisodes, where the hosts share strange, humorous, or harrowing stories submitted by their community. A defining feature of the show is its evolution over time, frequently revisited through their Rewind episodes. These segments offer a nostalgic look at their journey, highlighting how they have grown from a fledgling project into a collaborative environment that prioritizes listener interaction and accountability. From discussing the chaos of modern life and travel mishaps to honoring the resilience of survivors and activists, Karen and Georgia create a community-driven atmosphere that is as thought-provoking as it is entertaining. If you enjoy a blend of morbid curiosity, candid life advice, and historical discovery, this is a show that keeps the conversation evolving, one mystery at a time.