Dead Certain: The Martha Moxley Murder

Summary

On October 30, 1975, the quiet, affluent enclave of Belle Haven, Connecticut, was shattered by the brutal murder of 15-year-old Martha Moxley. For decades, the case has remained a haunting fixture in the American consciousness, marked by privilege, high-profile connections, and a legal saga that resulted in a controversial murder conviction later overturned. Dead Certain: The Martha Moxley Murder transcends the typical true-crime formula by acting as both a deep-dive investigative series and a meditation on the elusive nature of justice. Host Andrew Goldman, who spent years researching the case for a book, brings an insider’s perspective to this enduring mystery. Throughout the series, Goldman pivots from analyzing the intimate diary entries of Martha herself to scrutinizing overlooked forensic leads, such as neglected police reports and suspicious statements from individuals at the scene. The podcast is defined by its refusal to accept a neat resolution. By exploring alternate theories—including the involvement of other potential suspects and the conflicting testimonies of key witnesses—Goldman highlights how memory, bias, and time can obscure the truth. Whether examining the personal life of the victim or the systemic failures of the original investigation, this series serves as a gripping look at why some questions remain unanswered fifty years later. It is an essential listen for those interested in the collision of celebrity, law, and the chilling reality of cold cases that refuse to stay buried.

Updated Jul 2, 2026