Betrayal and Final Convictions

In October of nineteen ninety nine A nine hundred eleven dispatcher in Austin, Texas was nearing the end of a long night shift when a strange call came in Caller was a man who just said his guts had been blown out of his stomach. The dispatcher asked him to explain what actually happened, but the caller wouldn't say. He just kept saying that you know he had woken up and his guts were hanging out and now he's holding his guts in with his hand and he needed an ambulance R now Before we get into that story If you're a fan of the strange Dark and mysterious delivered in story format, and you've come to the right place because that's all we do, so if that's of interest to you, please sneak into the Fllow buttons house and add hot sauce to the solution for their eye contacts Let's get into today's story. Aobbe Firefly is the all in one creative studio with AI powered image and video editing for today's creative process built for creators of every kind. Firefly helps you generate, edit, and experiment fast Because the asks aren't getting smaller budgets aren't getting bigger, and the timelines, oh yeah, still tight With all the best creative AI models in one place, Firefly brings your ideas to life. Unlock a better way to make with Adobe Firefly You know, recommendations can be great. Maybe someone recommended this podcast, and here you are But home projects are different. If a podcast isn't your thing, you lose a few minutes. If you hire your cousin's neighbor to mount your TV, you might end up with a lopsided screen and wall damage. Maybe I know a guy just isn't enough for your home. And That's why Thumb Tack works. It matches you with top rated local pros with photos, reviews, and credentials all in one place For your next home project, try Thumbtack. Hire the R proro today. On the night of october first, nineteen ninety nine, a seventy five year old man named Steve Beard sat on the patio of his mansion in Austin, Texas sipping on a cocktail. And it was a great night, warm evening, the leaves rustling in the trees all around his property, and behind his house there was this crereeak that was flowing along, and in the house, he could hear his wife Celeste washing the dishes So Steve had met Celeste only about six years ago. It was actually shortly after his first wife, Elise had died of cancer. and Steve had been with his first wife for forty five years, and they'd raised three kids together. And he'd just been totally lost after she had passed away And really after she had died, he had spent a lot of nights just sitting alone at the Austin Country Club where actually Celeste had been working as a waitress Celeste was only thirty years old at the time, which meant she was almost forty years younger than Steve, but there had been an immediate spark between them, and they got married just over a year later Some of Steve's friends and family had immediately assumed that, you know, given this age gap Celeste was simply after Steve for his money Steve after all, had made a fortune as a business owner and a TV station executive, and he was worth about ten million dollars But Steve knew that money could not possibly be the only thing Celeste saw in him. I mean, he knew that he took great care of Celeste and also he took great care of her twin teenage daughters. I mean, he really helped give Celeste and her girls the stability that they desperately needed. However Despite that stability, one thing that Celeste had always struggled with for much of her life was depression And in fact, earlier that year It had gotten so bad that Celeste had actually tried to end her own life. And, you know, she had failed, she'd lived As a result of that attempt, she'd spent a few weeks in a psychiatric hospital Now of course, that was a really traumatic and awful thing for the family But from Steve's perspective, the upside of this was that Celeste was put on some new medication as a result of this hospital stay. She had made some good friends actually while she was at the hospital and to Steve, it just seemed like, you know, maybe now thingsings were starting to maybe turn around for Celeste. And to Steve, the fact that Celeste appeared to be on the right path again was great timing becausecause recently Steve had actually been dealing with health problems of his own Twice in the past few months, Steve had passed out and actually had to be hospitalized himself The doctors told him he had high blood pressure, sleep apnea, and he had some heart and kidney issues They actually couldn't quite figure out why he was fainting. They just knew he had you know several symptoms going on Now, Steve thought it was very likely stress related and he just needed to relax. So in fact, in two days from now, he was going to be taking Celeste on a three week vacation around Europe After everything Celeste had been through that year and also, you know, Steve had been through as well with his own medical issues, he felt like they both could use some time away, just the two of them. But now, when Steve got up from a seat out on the patio of his home and he He put the empty cocktail glass down on the table and he turned and he opened the glass door that led into the bedroom He saw that even though he'd already packed his suitcase for this European trip, you know several days ago, Celeste's suitcase was still empty in the closet, and Steve couldn't help but feel like It seems like Celeste might be getting cold feet about this European vacation, like she should have been packed already and she's clearly putting it off. So, Steve left the bedroom and he went down the hallway and went into the kitchen where he found Celeste cleaning up. And when he got in there, as gently as he could, he told Celeste, Hey, you know When you get a chance, you really ought to pack And she told him, Oh, don't worry about it. You know, she's just been busy all week. She'd get to it Steve nodded but wasn't really convinced that she actually intended to pack soon, but he said, okay And then he looked over at the clock, and even though it was barely nine PM, he felt exhausted. So he told Ceest he was going go to bed she told him that she actually intended to stay up for a bit longer. One of her daughters was having a sleepover at the family's lakehouse that night, and she said that she might go over there and just check on them later Sluss told Steve that when she returned from doing that, she would sleep in a different room to avoid waking him up Steve thanked her and gave herkis goodnight, and then he turned and walked back down the hallway back into the bedroom. He got ready for bed, climbed into bed, and then he put on his oxygen mask because he had sleep apnea, and then he pulled the covers up and he drifted off to sleep Hours later, around three AM Steve woke up and immediately he felt this horrible pain in his stomach And even though it was dark in his room, he looked down, you know, he's got the mask still on his face And he could tell there was something on his stomach. And he reached down instinctively and he grabbed at his stomach And he felt something wet on his hands And so in a panic, he ripped off his mask and he kind of sat up to look down at his abdomen. But as he did, just the pain he felt intensified so much just by trying to sit up that he fell back down. And so he reached over and he clicked on the light and he looked down and there was blood all over his stomach, like all over the sheets everywhere. And so he begins screaming out for Celeste. And as he's screaming like the pain is only getting worse and worse And Celeste is not coming in the room. She's not even responding. And so as he's looking down, like completely panic stricken, watching all this blood coming out of his gut, he has no idea how this is happening. He just reached over and grabbed the phone And he dialed nine hundred and eleven Just minutes later, a squad car from the Travis County Sheriff's Department pulled up outside of Steve's house with its lights flashing Deputy Allan Howard climbed out of that car, and he saw a fire captain and another pair of deputies on the front step pounding on the door All Deputy Howard knew was that a man in this home had called in with some kind of medical emergency The dispatcher had not quite understood what was wrong with him And so Howard just ran over to the front door. and there, the other deputies told him that so far nobody was answering their knocks Howard knew at this point, you know, time is of the essence. They had to get in and make sure this person was okay. And so he didn't want to just sit out here and wait any longer. So he left the front porch and he went along the side of the house to see if there was maybe another door that was unlocked somewhere else. And so as Howard went around to the side of the property, the other deputies followed him And then Howard, he eventually found this flight of stairs that went up to a patio attached to a bedroom And so up Howard went, the deputies followed, they got up there, and they looked into the house and they saw a light was on And then through the glass door, they could all see there was an elderly man laying in bed with a telephone receiver in one hand and his other hand appeared to be just covered in blood Howard walked up to the door and tried to open it, but it was locked. So he pulled out his heavy duty flashlight and he broke the glass, reached in, unlocked it, and slowid the door open Then Howard ran into the bedroom and when he got right next to the bed, he looked at this man who was still conscious, but he had a gaping hole in his stomach, like his intestines were literally spilling out. And that's why his other hand was so covered in blood. It was like he was trying to. hold his intestines inside of himself. Howard asked the guy what happened? And the old man just said he had no idea. He'd just woken up and his guts were coming out. At this point, the fire captain came into the room, and while he knelt down with his first aid kit to try to bandage up this man's wounds Howard began looking around the bedroom for any clue about what was going on here And he noticed something that was round and yellow lying on the carpet. So he bent down to get a better look, and he saw that the round yellow thing was a shotgun shell And so at this point, it seemed fairly obvious that this man has been shot in the stomach with a shotgun But Howard's also realizing that Whoever pulled the trigger might still be in the house So at this point, Howard drew his own weapon and he crept slowly out into the hallway And as Howard began searching the rest of the house He didn't find anybody, but what he did find is there were lots of other entry points into the home, lots of doors and windows. And eventually when he found his way into the living room, he saw there was another set of sliding glass doors. and he walked right up to it and he found They were unlocked Howard also saw that a table lamp in this living room was overturned, suggesting that somebody might have knocked it over while coming in or out of the house. And so Howard continued searching the living room and then he found his way into the dining room. kitchen and then he went down a hallway into another wing of the house There, he opened another door to a bedroom And he found there was a woman inside, sleeping in her bed totally sound asleep At this point, Howard lowered the weapon and he flipped on a light woman immediately startled awake. And she was about to ask like what's going on here? but Howard just stopped her and he told her that he was with the shheriff's deepartment and they were here responding to a nine hundred eleven call. and he told her that The man in the other room was very badly injured, and he had called nine hundred eleven And so the woman, you, as she's processing what she's being told, she began sobbing hysterically and then just begged Howard not to let her husband die And then a second later, in the midst of all this chaos This teenage girl comes running in the room and goes right to the woman and she grabs her the way a child would grab their mother and they're sort of like holding each other and Dpeputy Howard, like he's looking for potentially a shooter in the house But just from the looks of it, it appeared very much like this is a woman who's very shocked, very shaken up by this The girl, the teenager as well, appears equally shocked. But just to be sure, Howard asked this woman to identify herself and through tears, she would say that her name was Celeste Beard and that very likely the victim here, the person you're talking about, the man is her husband, Stephven Beard And then she also said that the teenage girl was her daughter And so now Howard feeling pretty confident that these are just victims He told them to just stay put that he was going to search the rest of the house and just make sure that the house was safe. And so Howard, he leaves the room, he can still hear them crying behind him And he searches the rest of the house, huge house, but he searches every room. There's nobody there. So it appeared that whoever had shot Steve was gone. isn't something that's talked about much, but it's a feeling we all know well When daily life gets in the way, it can feel impossible to measure up to our beloved pets' unconditional love Traveling for work is never the hard part. Leaving behind my six cats and three dogs is. My daily routine goes from loud and chaotic to way too quiet But one thing I never compromise on is their health and nutrition. Every one of them is on Hill's pet nutrition, so I know they're getting exactly what they need to stay happy and strong And so even when I'm away, missing all the barking, the purring, the nonstop attention, I still have peace of mind because they're not just pets, they're family You're doing better than you think you are. And Hill's pet nutrition is here to help make this whole pet parenting thing easier with science led nutrition to support their unique needs and lifelong health You can feel confident that you're doing right by your pet and taking care of them with guilt free meals they can't get enough of Because you're only human, there's hills. Science does more Ready to give more love than humanly possible? Find your pet's new favorite food at hillspet dot com slash Ballen. That's hillspet dot com slash Bain. Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start, Thumbtech knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin, or what that clunking sound from your dryer is.ith Thumbtech, you don't have to be a home pro You just have to hire one. You can hire top rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today. We've all heard those scary IRS radio ads that try to frighten you into calling, but tax relief advocates is different. If you owe the IRS five thousand, fifty thousandars or even five hundred thousand dollars, TRA has a solution for your tax problem It doesn't matter if you're in your car at work or with your kids, no matter where you are, visit tRA. comot Don't lose hope. TRA could reduce or even eliminate what you owe. Their passion is taxes and helping people and businesses fix IRS problems. They have over one thousand five star Google reviews and an A plus rating with the Better Business Bureau You no longer need to fear the IRS. Generous tax relief programs are available now to give you a fresh start, so don't wait. Simply visit tra dot com that's tra dot com or call eight hundred five eight three six four two nine. Once again, that's eight hundred five eight three six four two nine tax relief advocates, real solutions for real people Around five thirty AM on october second, nineteen ninety nine, so about two and a half hours after Steve Beard called nine hundred and eleven Sergeant Paul Knight walked through the waiting room at a hospital in Austin, Texas. Knight was a criminal investigator for the Travis County Sheriff's Department. and he'd been called in to lead the investigation into this shooting. Knight stopped at the front desk and he spoke to a nurse him that Steve Beard was in critical condition, so questioning him would not be possible right now. Sergeant Knight nodded and gave the nurse' a card and asked them to give him a call if Steve's condition ever stabilized. As Knight turned to leave, he quickly scanned the waiting room And he saw in the corner, there was a deputy speaking to a woman who appeared to be in her thirties as well as a teenage girl. The deputy waved tonight and called him over And so Knight went over and he introduced himself The woman told Knight that she was Steve's wife Celeste, and the girl was her daughter, Christina night you know he said hello to them, but he knew that he had to do something that was going to come off as pretty insensitive, but he really had to do it as soon as possible. So after just, you know, exchanging some pleasantries He sat down and pulled out a gunpowder residue test kit And then he asked Celeste and Christina if he could swab their hands before they began really getting into any sort of conversation here And Celeste looked really surprised and asked if she was a suspect And I'd explained that really at this point Everybody was a suspect And so swabbing them for gunpowder would be the quickest way to rule them both out So Celeste, who is still very clearly shaken up, she just put both her hands out and Kight ran a test strip across both of them. And then after that, Christina put her hands out and he tested her hands as well And then he waited for the test strips to develop. And about a minute later. He confirmed that they were both negative, meaning neither of them had fired a gun recently And so with this test out of the way, Knight's entire demeanor sort of softened And he asked Celeste to just walk him through what had happened that night She told him that her husband, Steve had gone to bed around nine or nine thirty And shortly after that She had left their home and driven over to the family's lakehouse to check on her other daughter, Jennifer and her friends, who were having a sleep over there. She said the lake house was about a half an hour away, and so by the time she finally came back after checking on Jennifer and the other girls She said it was about midnight. And you know, she walked in the house and it was quiet. there was nothing unusual And she said she went straight to bed And she said she actually chose to sleep in a different room than Steve because Steve had gone to bed earlier and she had told him she didn't want to wake him up if she came home late. And so she was doing him a courtesy by sleeping in this other room Knight asked Celeste if she knew anybody who might be mad at her husband or who might want to hurt him for any reason, And she said no But she did say that the previous afternoon, her husband had gone out and cashed a really big check. He was gonna to give some cash to her twin daughters, you know while she and Steve were going to be in Europe. He wanted to give the kids some spending money while they were away. and it was quite a bit of money. And so she said, you know, maybe somebody at the bank saw him cashing that check knew he had a bunch of money on him. Maybe they followed him home to rob him And so Kight and Celeste spoke for a little bit longer And then when Kight was done questioning her Cest got up and said she was going to go outside and smoke a cigarette as she left Kight turned to her daughter, Christina. and asked her about what she'd seen and heard from the previous night Christina said she had been asleep all night until around three thirty in the morning when she'd woken up to police lights flashing outside her window And as she continued to tell her story of what happened. Kight noticed that she was being really careful about what she was saying. Not like she was trying to remember some concocted story, but rather it was like she was literally trying her best to actually remember. likeike she was struggling to remember what amounted to a pretty traumatic and very you know, chaotic night. Before Kight could ask any more follow up questions, another girl, another teenager, who looked exactly like Christina, ran into the waiting room and immediately Christina got up to go over and hug her two girls pulled away from each other Knight noticed that both of these girls were sobbing, and they really were just like identical. Christina introduced this new girl as her twin sister, Jennifer. And then just a few seconds after that, two teenage boys came through the hospital door and they hurried over to join the group And as they all sat down Christina explained that the two boys were her and Jennifer's boyfriends. After Christina briefly updated her sister, Jennifer and the two boyfriends about the condition of her stepfather, Knight turned to Jennifer and just asked her to please walk him through where she had been, you know, the previous night. And Jennifer would say, you know, she had been at the family's lakehouse, she was there with her boyfriend and one other friend. She'd been there all night And then when they had found out something had happened to Steve, they had all rushed here as soon as they could. And so Kight, he asked the girls if either of them knew anyone who might want to harm their stepfather as soon as he asked that Kight noticed the two teenage girls, they shared this quick, knowing look between themselves. At this point, Christina turned back to Knight and said, There was only one person she could think of who would do something like this, a woman named Tracy Tarleton She explained that Tracy was a friend of her mother's, and they'd met earlier that year at a psychiatric hospital where they had both been patients. But Christina said, there was just something off about their friendship Tracy seemed like really unstable And Christina got the feeling that she was actually in love with their mom And as soon as she said this, all four of the teens just sort of nodded knowingly. like this was something they definitely had talked about internally And then they all began to agree out loud that Tracy very likely was the one who did this. And then a minute later, a fifth teenager came running into the hospital and they They joined the group and Jennifer introduced her as another friend. Her name was Amy Coosart and she had been the other friend sleeping over at the lakehouse that night. And Amy, who literally had just joined and heard, you know no context to this point about anything the other teenagers had said, You know, when she was asked pretty much right away by night, if she knew of anyone who might have wanted to hurt Steve, she didn't hesitate. She just said, Oh, Tracy Tarton Later that afternoon around three o'clock Sergeant Knight knocked on the front door of Tracy Tarleton's very unassuming ranch style house in a working class part of Austin, Texas While running a check on Tracy to confirm her address, he'd also discovered that she had a weapons permit for a twenty gauge shotgun, the same caliber as the casing that was found inside the crime scene Tracy answered the door pretty much right away, as if she had been waiting for someone to come by and Kight, after introducing himself, told her that Steve Beard had been shot He said this He didn't notice any shock on Tracy's face. Instead Tracy actually looked scared Knight asked Tracy if she had any idea who might have shot Steve. And she said, no But then she asked if she needed a lawyer The Kight said, Well, that's up to you And then before she could really react to that, he asked her if he could come inside Tracy just sort of turned and led him into the living room Knight walked in, he sat down, and he just continued talking to Tracy. And so he asked her about her relationship with Celeste she said that yes, they had met at a psychiatric hospital when they were both being treated earlier that year for suicide attempts. And then sort of unannounced, she told the detective that at first, when she had met Celeste, her feelings towards Celeste had not been platonic. they had been romantic. She had been interested in Celeste as a partner. She then quickly clarified and said that was in the past and that now they really were just friends And so Knight took stock of this and didn't really ask too many follow up questions on their relationship And instead, he just said, okay, well Where were you the night before? And Tracy said she had been here at her house the whole time She said that she had ordered pizza and she'd had a few beers and then had just gone to bed. Kight asked her if she owned a gun then Tracy said, Yes But she only used it for sket shooting Iight asked if he could see her gun And so Tracy got up and she walked over and opened up a closet, and she pulled out a shotgun in a zippered case. Knight asked her if he could take her gun down to the ballistics department And Tracy definitely hesitated for a moment But then she was like Later that same day, Sergeant Knight walked through the crime scene at the Beard Msion, looking for any clues that the investigators might have missed during the initial search. Celeste's twin daughters, Christina and Jennifer had actually come with him to help point out anything that could be out of place that he wouldn't necessarily notice Inside of Steve's bedroom, Knight saw that some of the drawers and closets had been left open, as if they had been ransacked by a burglar Something about the whole scene just didn't seem right drawers, they didn't appear to have been ripped open as if somebody was in a rush. They had been pulled out really carefully, and inside the drawer, things were basically pretty neat. And so tonight, this didn't really appear to be a burglary He suspected that someone might have staged the crime scene to appear to be a burglary to throw off the investigation However, just for good measure, he asked the twin girls to look through all of these open drawers and closets to see if you can identify anything that was missing And so the girls began looking around and eventually Christina said that she couldn't find Stephven's watch or his sapphire ring. Now, on the one hand, this might give credit to the idea that this really was a burglary gone wrong. You know that Steve was just sort of in the wrong place at the wrong time and got shot by the burglar. But tonight, this development that these two small items were gone actually only seem to confirm the idea that this was not a burglary gone wrong because this whole house was chock full of nice jewelry and antiques. There's so many other things in the house that could have been taken that were obvious, that were not taken And so night he left the bedroom, walked down the hallway, and went into the living room. and there he's looking around at all this obviously very expensive furniture and vases and paintings and all this stuff that's super valuable all over the place. He began to consider another possibility Maybe somebody in the family had killed Steve for the inheritance. I mean, this guy clearly is loaded. Now Knight didn't know what Ste's Will said yet But he knew that, along with his two stepdaughters, he had three adult children from his first marriage. And all of them very likely stood to inherit millions of dollars when he died And then there was Steve's wife, Celeste, who was less than half his age It was hard not to wonder if she'd simply married him for his money. And so it wasn't really a far cry to wonder if maybe she had been involved in the shooting, because if he dies, maybe she'd get all of his money And so as Kight was thinking about this and wandering back down the hallway He noticed a trap door in the ceiling that led to an attic that he hadn't noticed before. Curious, he reached up and pulled opened the door, and then he climbed up the ladder that came down and before long he was in the attic And up in the attic, he saw there was a box lying on the floor just a few feet away And you know, where everything else in the attic had been totally covered in dust and cobwebs This box was not. It was perfectly clean, as if it had only been put up here pretty recently So he grabbed the box and he opened the lid up and inside was a twenty gauge shotgun Knight knew this could be extremely important to this case, so he immediately packaged up the box, picked it up, and he carried it down the ladder back down to the main floor. And when he got down there, he saw one of the twin girls, Jennifer staring at him looking really nervous. She rushed to explain that that shotgun She had purchased as an anniversary gift for her boyfriend, and she was just keeping it up there out of sight until it was time to give it to him She swore the gun had never been fired and she had not even taken it out of the box yet. Knight heard what she said, but He held on to the box because he still was going to bring it back to the ballistics department right away to have it tested It seemed very odd to him that Jennifer hadn't mentioned until now that there was a gun in the house and that it just happened to be the exact same gun, same caliber as the weapon that was used to shoot Steve Jennifer did have an alibi. She had been at the lakehouse at that sleepover thirty miles away on the night of Steve's shooting Her sister, Christina, had been home the whole night I' had to wonder if Maybe the two sisters had plotted together to kill their stepfather. Maybe for his money After all, it just seemed weirdly convenient that Jennifer, Christina, their boyfriends, their other friend Amy, had all, without any hesitation, named Tracy Tarlleton as the suspect It just seemed like something here was not quite adding up Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start, Thumbtch knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin, or what that clunking sound from your dryer is. With Thumbtch, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today You've all heard those scary IRS radio ads that try to frighten you into calling. but tax relief advocates is different. If you owe the IRS five thousand, fifty thousandars or even five hundred thousand dollars, TRA has a solution for your tax problem. It doesn't matter if you're in your car, at work or with your kids, no matter where you are, visit tRA dot com Don't lose hope. TRA could reduce or even eliminate what you owe. Their passion is taxes and helping people and businesses fix IRS problems. They have over a thousand five star Google reviews and an A plus rating with the Better Business Bureau. You no longer need to fear the IRS. Generous tax relief programs are available now to give you a fresh start so don't wait Simply visit tra dot com That's tra dot com or call eight hundred five eight three six four two nine. Once again, that's eight hundred five eight three six four two nine, tax relief advocates, real solutions for real people That evening, Detective Knight went back to the hospital and the nurse at the front desk told him that Steve was out of surgery and was stable enough to finally have visitors. She gave him Steve's room number and then let him through However, when he got down the hallway to Steve's room, he saw this handwritten sign taped to the door that said no law enforcement personnel allowed to interview patient except in the presence of his attorney. And as Knight was processing this pretty surprising sign, Out of nowhere, Steve's wife, Celeste came rushing down the hallway and literally blocked him from going into the room She said that for one, she was not going to allow any further searches of her and Steve's house Police wanted to speak to her husband? They'd have to go through the family's lawyer And night, I mean, he was stunned by this because in all his years on the Force, He had never seen a victim hire a defense attorney. And then more than that, Knight wasn't even sure if Steve was the one who made this decision. I Steve was stable now, but he really had no idea if he was actually conscious. You know, was it was it Steve who decided to put up this roadblock or was it Celeste? So at this point, Knight really didn't know what he was legally allowed to do here And so, you know, using an abundance of caution, he just turned around left, at least for now And as he, you know walked out of the hospital He tried to make sense of why Celeste was suddenly being so defensive. You know even if she was not the one who made this decision, the way she had just treated him in the hallway was just very aggressive. And then he began to wonder if maybe she had heard about the gun that he had found in their attic She was now trying to just protect her daughters, or maybe she was trying to protect herself. On the afternoon of october seventh, so five days after Steve Beard was shot Sergeant Poul Knight looked through a folder of interview notes at his desk. By this point, he'd spoken to all three of Steve's own children, his adult children They were all ruled out as suspects because they all lived hours away and had solid alibis When Knight had asked one of Steve's sons if he knew who might have done this, he told the detective to look into Celeste. I mean, after all, pretty much they all thought she was in this marriage for money to begin with. But, you know, Knight had tested Celeste for gunshot residue right after the shooting So he knew she literally could not have been the one who pulled the trigger And so at this point tonight, it just sort of felt like the entire family was just pointing fingers at each other At the same time, Knight did feel like at least one family member on some side of the family was likely involved in the shooting. There was just frankly too much money at stake here In particular, it was definitely suspicious that Celeste's daughter Jennifer had a twenty gauge shotgun in the attic And on top of that She and her twin sister, Christina and all of their friends had immediately pointed the finger at Tracy Tarton And then as for Tracy, I mean, she did have a pretty weak alibi and she did own a twenty gauge shotgun. But despite that, she had absolutely no history of doing anything violent like this. And she was remarkably cooperative and had even handed over her shotgun for analysis without really any fight at all. And so at this point, Knight knew he really just needed to speak directly to Steve family's attorney was preventing the police from seeing him And Knight wasn't sure how stable his condition was, or really how much longer he would even be alive for. So like this was a very tenuous situation. But just then, Knight noticed something out of the corner of his eye and he looked up And he saw there was another detective in the doorway of his office just sort of leaning there with a big smile on their face. Knight asked them what was going on, and the detective walked over and handed him a Manila folder And he told him This was a forensics report. they had just gotten back A piece of evidence that had been found at the crime scene may have just cracked the entire case basased on forensic evidence confessions and witness interviews This is what police believe happened to Steve Beard in the early morning hours of october second, nineteen ninety nine aroundround two thirty AM Killer turned off their headlights as they drove toward the Beard mansion parked at the back entrance to the property far away from the house, so the noise of their engine wouldn't wake anybody up inside They got out of the car, slim a shotgun over their shoulder, and began walking through the trees towards the mansion patio came into view They stopped They felt sick and they actually didn't want to go through with this They had made a promise They had to do it. So they swallowed their fear continued walking towards the mansion And when they got right to the steps that would lead up to the patio They went to the right. And they walked to a separate door that led into the living room. class door was unlocked. So they opened it up, they stepped inside, Once inside, they navigated their way to the main bedroom. And they went inside the main bedroom They found Steve asleep in his bed Killer walked to the foot of the bed just stared at Steve for a second Then when they were ready, they raised the shotgun in their shaking hands. They pulled the trigger The blast was deafening. Bood began pouring out of Steve's abdomen immediately. The killer reflexively racked the shotgun, ejecting the shotgun shell, getting ready to fire a second time if need be