Why Fans Defend the NFL

Heat up your fourourth of July at the Home Depot with our wide variety of grills under three hundred dollars and make every gathering one to remember. Give your outdoor space a glow up. Wh whatever your budget is, with savings on seasonal plants starting at five dollars. With the grill fired up and your backyard set to perfection, you'll be able to invite friends and family over to kick off the party Start celebrating with low prices guaranteed at the Home Depot. Prices may vary h stor exisions the price see Home Depot com sign priceash for details Somewhere between the first drive and settling in at the clubhouse, goolf becomes more than just a game Lulu Lemon golf gear is built for the full range of your day lightight layers as you head to early tea times Flexible fits move naturally with your swing Our fabrics workick sweat and block UVs for hours in the sun And refined cuts carry you well into the nineteenth poll. Shop golf gear in stores and online at lulemon d. com e Perlman has been a frequent guest of our show. He has written ten books that are New York Times bestestsellers. You can follow him at TikTok at Jeff Pearlman, author on TikTok. He's got a ton of followers, a really unique following. He's the author of Only God Can Judge Me The Many Lives of Tupac Shakor and also season four of his very popular YouTube show Press Box Chronicles. It debuts on Monday He and I are coming under some criticism. I actually borrowed the take from him, gave him credit for it. But when he mentioned the Michael Strahan interview with Chris Johnson, he brought up something that I had not considered and I agreed with him. And now people are calling us ghouls because he said that Michael Strahan as a football player has to ask Chris Johnson questions about football somewhere within context of the conversation. Jeff, thank you for joining us. What did you think and what did you feel of the criticism I'm not just saying this. I think as I get older, it doesn't really bother me nearly as much as I used to I just think Dan you and I were brought up as journalists in aas decreasingly less journalistic age. And to me If you have a football player who is coming to say he has ALS And There there was a study just a couple of years ago from Boston University in Harvard saying that NFL players are four times more likely to get ALS than general people, general population to not ask anything about it Not just that in. they also had an expert on ALS on the same segment and didn't ask her about it Um Num one, it doesn't make any sense. and number two, it's just inexcusably bad journalism. And number three, it speaks to the power of the NFL, the power of the shhield. Let's keep as far away from this connection as we can Do you think it's fair to absorb all of this uncomfortably and put it in the file of this is exactly why I hate journalists. The man is speaking through a machine. What difference does your journalism make? don' I don't agree with that at all. It actually bothers me Here's the thing about it that I keep thinking As I just said, the NFL doesn't want people to think about the negative impacts of football on the human body. They want us to cheer and love the shiny helmets and go to the games and buy our fifteen dollarars pretzels. They want that. They want you to be happy watching Fotball There's a reason the NFL never has a CTE awareness day doesnn't have them where it doesn't doesn never paintts on the endzone, CT awareness, ALS awareness. They don't wind you aware of it So when people come along and say, how dare you ask these questions? How can you ask these incentive questions First of all As you know and as you've done, journalists do ask insensitive questions. It's sort of part of the job. And number two, to not ask it to not bring it up, to not even mention it is basically going along with the entire NFL narrative that they want you to do. and neither you nor I are paid by the NFL Why though is it an insensitive question? It's just a question I don't even think it's an incentive quest. I get wait Chris Johnson posted on his social media when he announced his diagnosis, he actually had a notation about the Boston University study and that NFL players are four times more likely. So the idea that it's somehow insensitive or wrong, would he actually evoked it as well? To me, it is far more ghoulish F more goulish. what the NFL does every day. and I love football, but what the NFL does every day with theirir Don't let's not talk about it. let's not think about it. Let's not bring it up To me, I spoke with a former NFL player about this. We were talking. Um How about lifetime health insurance How about I would even say it was it was Tony Mandriton and I had this talk on his on a TikTok live the other day. He's like, I would just love them to pay for my stretch lab membership because I'm in so much pain sometimes How about taking care of your players not getting mad at the messenger, but getting mad at these people who every time an NFL player fights a claim files a claim, the NFL is fighting it Howb about taking care of your players? and then maybe we wouldn't have to have this conversation. They don't fight it on ALS though. Mike Florio has pointed out and I'm just going to read directly here at one level, it didn't really need to be mentioned. The connection has been established. For example, ALS is one of the specific conditions along with Parkinson's, Alzheimer's, early in moderate dementia, and certain cases of CTE diagnosis after death Automatically qualified retired players as of july seventh, twenty fourteen for no questions asked compensation from the NFL's unlimited concussion settlement fund. And in twenty twenty one, a study of all nineteen thousand four hundred twenty three NFL athletes who played between nineteen sixty and twenty nineteen and played one or more professional games resulted in a finding that risks of developing ALS four times as high nearly as those of the general population. So the science of this seems pretty conclusive, but let me just read to you, Jeff, some of the things being said by people and ask you why it is that this is happening. So and I should mention, I've asked these people to come on with us and have the conversation. I don't even want to argue or debate. I'm just curious what's happening here And they've all declined and this person at Zack Zack Zack said that we didn't even have permission to use his tweet, which is public, but he writes Dan is a hack and Parlman is such a blowhard for this. Dan hasn't asked a critical question to a guest in eight years. Perlman is mad that Straayhand didn't try to get Chris Johnson to blame football for his ALS diagnosis. Ghoulish weirdos Both of them just look at the replies. Peter Bkowski writes, I know Perlman thinks he's the omniscient ombudsman of everyone, but the idea Michael Straayhan, not a journalist, has some ethical responsibility to ask a question to a player who couldnot speak due to a crippling illness is ghoulish and representative of why so many hate the media. I'm going to keep going here Just so that people can get a feel for this. This asshole really wanted Straayhand to ask a man talking through a machine, hard hitting and gripping questions. Since when are we looking to Michael Straayhand for hard hitting journalism? He's on GMA because he's a charismatic host who's willing to read the script. There are many more, but your thoughts here No one you just perfectly Surmise why I'm so happy I left Twitter like two years ago Um But number two, okay, let's actually flip this a little bit. Yourre Micha was Straay handand You say you ask Chris Johnson several questions And then you say, I have to ask, U As you post on your social media NFO players are four times more likely to, um contract ALS then you know, if you had never played Youour young father You're, you know, you should be entering the prime of your life. Do you at all regret playing football? or do you view it differently? And maybe he says You know what? it was the best years of my life. It made me it gave me money that made my family secure for life. I have no regrets. I know this is part of it. And that would be a great answer And maybe he says I have tons of regret. I sit here now at forty years old and I wish I'd never picked up a football And that's a great answer. It's not setting a person up to give you the answer that you want There actually is no answer you want. It's just a question in light of the science of it all that needs to be asked and the number of times that some guy has CT, some guy has LS, some guy has some injury And it's not the right time It's not the right time to ask me. Why are you asking now? How dare you ask now? Why don't you wait till later? What an inappropriate time to ask you a question. You hear that over and over. So when exactly is the right time? Do we ask after he died Do we ask his weeping widow after he died at the funeral, after the funeral? What exactly is the right time? If not now, when he is sitting in front of you and Again, he has already put on social media made note of the ties between AOS and football. When is the right time for these people Would you have been satisfied with the question, would you let your child play football? I think it's a great question. one hundred percent But it would have been enough, just one question because part of the reason you went viral for this, I believe is people feel sort of helpless and uncomfortable. They're looking, where's the person I could yell at because this is on my TV screen and I don't want to be looking at how any of this feels, but also your TikTok that sparked the conversation was titled Chris Johnson has ALS Media Cowards Reuseed to address ties between the disease and football, shame. Wait Dan, I actually this is in a way is like a bigger issue. A couple months ago when the Dallas wings drafted Ay Fud number one overall And last year they used the number one pick on page backackers, right And these are both players out of UCon, players who dated who were very open about their relationship And Ay Fudge is a lengthy ESPN interview, not one question about Paage Beckers. She does another interview on a major network, not one interview about Paage Beckers. It's sets an obvious question, right? Oh, you're playing Are you excited to be playing with your girlfriend or ex girlfriend? Are you concerned about it? What do you thinkking about it It's an obvious question. The leeague clearly Clearly deterred these outlets from asking Here again, you have a player ALS Um, dying of the disease. the disease is tied to football It is an obvious question and obviously the leeague or someone affiliated with the league is telling Michael Strahan urging ABC withith Disney Tides, obviously ESPN not to ask the question To me, it is just a increasingly narrow gap between corporate interests and journalistic interests. And people buy into it because they love the Titans or they love the jets and they love watching the games and they want to be comfortable watching their sports. All those people on Twitter, they want to be comfortable watching sports. I'm going to do the ALS challenge. Look, here's acket of my head. I'm challenging my friend to do it now and my other friend to do it. and the attentions are good. I'm not saying that But at some point someomeone has to address the ties between this and this. And do I think that would have been enough of a question? No, but at least it would have been a question Well, when you say someone has to do it among the criticisms, Jeff, context matters. I'm going to keep reading a couple of these. context matters. The interview was more to announce that CJ is battling ALS. That's not the time to ask him if he blames football. It was a human interest piece, not investigative journalism. Someone else writes, No, he doesn't have that responsibility. This is kind of gross. Guy went on GMA to reveal his ALS diagnosis and the horrible impact it already has to spread more awareness about the disease. The fact that you think it must be connected to football in that moment is so short sighted It's just ridiculous. Also Asking a question, let's say you ask Chris Johnson a question And he says, honestly, I don't really feel like talking about that or I don't want to address that now or I don't know enough to say Well that's fine That's fine. And how is that aect When do we get to a point, Dan where it is offensive to ask a question This guy he's a forty year old man who's dealing with ALS who again, put on social media about the ties between football and ALS When did we become so everyveryone talks about, oh, snowflakes, lipps. When did we become so soft of a culture that we're not allowed to ask questions anymore. That's never the right time. That's too, how dare you? It just honestly Again, journalistically, it drives me crazy and this is why I'm not on Twitter. Well, but one of the great heartbreaks of my life though, Jeff, is that my professional life is that people don't care about this stuff the way that you and I do. They don't thinkink about the things that go into the vetting of properly asked questions or information or the lawyering of stories. and in that, the distaste for journalism grows and journalism dies. So you and I are fighting what is empirically a losing fight Oh yeah. there's no doubt about it. And also Um comes down to I remember years ago when Jemelle Hill put out Donald Trump is a white supremacist, right? And the ESPN came down on her with the wrath of God, right And again, I'm not saying you should write to write or wrong to write it, but like it was a reminder Don't go against whatever the corporate overlord you have And as media becomes more and more and more and more corporate controlled, corporately controlled there are fewer people willing to actually say, wait a second, this isn't right or wait a second. that's wrong. because you're not just going against a league, you're going against the owner of your business. You're going against the same people who own ESPN and the same people own Yahoo, et cetera. So there are just fewer people I'm not saying I'm a truth teller, anything stupid like that. I'm just saying there are fewer people willing to say, wait a second How can you not ask that question? That's a real question to ask. There just aren't that many left And what's the cost of it for the country terrible Absolutely terrible. Cruption run amuck U This isn't a political podcast, but two days ago, New York Times reported Trump has made two billion dollars as a president. You would think the news was, oh, it's going to be warm on Tuesday. like not even a response. People don't trust the news. They don't listen to the news. We have eight thousand different Um, people feeding us information People who want to get this news just go to their source who would tell them what to believe. People want to get this news, go to their source. It's a broken It's a broken echo chamber that leads to a lot of people not even understanding what reporting is. You know? A lot of people just don't dam. a lot of people It's not that they object to what we do so much as they don't even understand what it is. Well, but because of that though, Jeff, I have found that I was naive in how America's appraisal of journalists is so low. They allowed Trump to win on a platform of trusting him more than the media. Oh yeah, it's crazy. Trust me, I'm the one you can listen to. I'm the only one who would tell you the truth so listen to me and it worked. Now one thing I will say, Dan that I am encouraged by is the rise of independent media All right People are just saying, forget this, I'm going out on my own. so you have people like Heather Cox Richardson U, you know, a million different independent journalists on substack and different formats We're putting out really good material and it's not corrupted. So I will say that is a good offshoot of this, but it's not a great time Average ALS patient survives three years after diagnosis, there's no cure. and I will remind you again that show friends, Tom Habtro and Book Chambi do a lot of great work here. Projectmainstreet dot org is where you can go. if you want to help people who are taking care of the people who need care who have ALS. Before I get you out of here, Jeff, can you tell me who you believe the responsibility first and foremost is when someone is interviewing Their primary responsibility is to whom first to the public and to the viewer hundred percent before the subject and before themselves. it's to the viewer. You are supposed to be a disperser of information and a feeder of knowledge. Like that's why most of us went into this business, I think The viewer is objecting to your appraisal here that that is the responsibility. I agree with you. I don't think the host's primary responsibility is to the guest or the employer. I think it's to the audience. but They're objecting to you and me here voicing something that is sort of a core principle that you and I believe in why Well wait Dan, I will tell you this, I'm being serious. I would say my comments on my feed for the video I did are overwhelmingly positive, including a bunch of DMs from people who either had a loved one who had AOS or somebody who played sports who wound up withOS. So I know you're seeing a lot of negative actually I'm not just saying this. I actually have seen more positive than negative. so maybe it's not as bad maybe it No, but the people following you are fans of you and you know that we're all in silos and echo chambers a lot and very often, the feedback you're getting from fans, I'm receiving something different for as I said, I'm parroting what you said and was sort of illuminated by it because I was surprised that I didn't also think it while it was happening because I was so uncomfortable and shocked, frankly, to see the fastest running back in sports at the time in that condition, I was so startled by it and so uncomfortable with it that I assume that this is where the vitriol is coming from. We want to blame somebody, Jeff when we're helpless. Like you don' you don't want to just be helpless and you made for an easy target by having an opinion that sort of, you know, that was a little bit of a few degrees away from wow, this is really uncomfortable to watch. This is I feel so bad for Chris Johnson. Yeah I'm I don' You know, Dan, I'm just being honest. likeike even thinking back when I was at SI and you would get letters written at S spports Illustrated Most of them were negative. Very few were positive. It was probably ten to one, you would get more negative letters than positive letters just because I think the people who are angry tend to speak out more than the people are like, oh, that's a good point. So I'm gonna maybe I'm living in my silo I'm going to choose to believe that there are many people out there who are like, yeah, that is a good question. ask. Yeah, that is ir responsseible one. Yeah, they are covering for the NFL. But I appreciate criticism. I find it generally constructive. It's useful very often. So when I ask you again T entertain the hypothetical and we'll get you out here in less than a minute, but just entertain the hypothetical that you and I have this all wrong. Why is this happening? Do you have a better theory than I think people feel helpless? They're mad. And so anyone if social media is just an outrage machine, you make for a convenient target when you offer an opinion that's just a couple of degrees separated from, man, this feels super shitty. I don't want to feel super shitty. Look at this asshole over here telling me that I should feel even shittier because Michael Strahand didn't do his job passate or did his job compassionately instead of critically I think people really want to love the NFL. They really want to love their teams. They really want to sit on their couch watch so and so run for so and so yards and wear their jersey that they bought at the NFL shop for one hundred and twenty dollars and wear their hat that they paid fifty dollars for and feel very, very, very comfortable. And the more people are reminded that football takes a significant toll in the lives of these players. The less comfortable they are sitting on their couch, wearing their hundred and twenty dollars jersey, wearing their fifty dollars hat, drinking their beer, cheering on their team. He has written ten bestselling books and you can follow him at Jeff Perlman, author on TikTok and also season four YouTube show, Press Box Chronicles. Thank you. Jeff. appreciate the time. Thank you, sir. All right, thanks Tony, you know that moment at a party or a tailgate where everything just sort of clicks. I know it well. It's usually when I show up, everybody goes crazy. Yeah, you usually take all the credit for it, but it's because Tony usually walks in with CQuer walking this. Yeah, yeah, yeah Quervo is the thing that turns hanging out into this is the night. It has that effect on people. It does. You usually take the credit for it but again