The Flop House
MaximumFun, Dan McCoy, Stuart Wellington, Elliott Kalan
Sonic the Hedgehog 3, with Jamelle Bouie
About This Episode
You probably thought we forgot the hedgehog beat! We were just biding our time. Sometimes slow and steady wins the race, SONIC. We welcome our returning Senior Hedgehog Correspondent, Jamelle Bouie, who absolutely does not have anything more important to do than extend this bit, to discuss Sonic the Hedgehog 3. Why does a movie about a fast hedgehog have this much plot, and why is it all so boilerplate? We get into it.
Stay updated on all things Flop House, plus a little extra, with our NEWSLETTER, “Flop Secrets!
Paste https://feeds.simplecast.com/EOAFriME into iTunes (or your favorite podcatching software) to have new episodes of The Flop House delivered to you directly, as they’re released.
Wikipedia page for Sonic the Hedgehog 3
Recommended in this episode:
Dan: The Color of Money (1986)
Stu: Pillion (2025)
Elliott: Heat Lightning (1934)
Jamelle Bouie: Wuthering Heights (1939)
Listen to The Flop House in Podtastic
For listeners, not advertisers
More Episodes
FH Mini 153 - Tops and Flops
In this inaugural episode of the new segment Tops and Flops, the hosts of The Flop House explore the filmographies of several acclaimed directors, ranking their best and worst works based on user ratings from an online movie database. The hosts provide their own insights into why certain films—from Steven Spielberg’s massive catalog to Sofia Coppola’s more intimate features—achieve critical adoration or fall flat with modern audiences. The discussion moves through the careers of Spike Lee, Ang Lee, Mike Leigh, and Kathryn Bigelow. Along the way, the hosts debate the impact of mainstream versus indie sensibilities, the challenges of sourcing older or harder-to-find titles on streaming platforms, and how public perception of a director can shift based on whether a film leans into spectacle or character-driven storytelling. While acknowledging that these rankings are subjective and often influenced by the biases of the voting public, the hosts provide humorous and thoughtful commentary on the highs and lows of these filmmakers, often discovering surprising gems or questioning why certain beloved movies remain lower in the rankings than expected.
Wuthering Heights
In this episode, the hosts of The Flop House dive into a discussion about the polarizing film adaptation of Emily Brontë’s classic novel, Wuthering Heights. The conversation begins with a lighthearted look at the film’s unique tone and its departure from the source material, with the hosts joking that it should have been titled Wuthering Heights-ish. The panel analyzes why the film—which features heavy-hitters like Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi—managed to be a financial success despite mixed critical reception. They explore the disconnect between the film’s lush, stylish cinematography and its inability to effectively translate the intense, gothic atmosphere of the novel. The hosts highlight the unconventional choices in the narrative, such as the addition of strange subtext and scenes that attempt to modernize or "extreme-ify" the classic romance, often to the detriment of the story’s pacing. Throughout the episode, the hosts offer sharp, humorous critiques on the casting, the film’s lack of narrative patience, and its tendency to favor "maximalist" imagery over emotional depth, ultimately questioning whether this adaptation successfully captures the spirit of the original Brontë work.
FH Mini 152 - Pride
In this episode of The Flop House Mini, the hosts are joined by special guest Alonzo Duralde, a renowned film critic and author, to discuss the evolution of queer representation in film. The conversation kicks off with a brief, humorous look at their shared history with the infamously obscure film After Last Season before transitioning into a thoughtful exploration of LGBTQ+ portrayals in cinema. The group reflects on their own experiences growing up and how they first identified queer characters on screen. They discuss the impact of negative stereotypes prevalent in 1980s and 90s media, analyzing how these depictions often colored their perceptions of real-world queer communities. The hosts highlight the difference between offensive caricatures and characters who, despite being presented through a stereotypical lens, retained dignity and agency within their narratives. Through examples ranging from Zorro the Gay Blade to the portrayal of friends in Mrs. Doubtfire and the subtext of films like Fried Green Tomatoes, the discussion explores the thin line between progress and regression in Hollywood's portrayal of LGBTQ+ life, ultimately focusing on how changing cultural perspectives have shifted the way these stories are told and understood.
The Mandalorian and Grogu, with Will Hines
In this episode of The Flop House, hosts Dan McCoy, Stuart Wellington, and Elliott Kalan are joined by guest Will Hines to discuss the Star Wars film The Mandalorian and Grogu. The group begins with a humorous tangent about the guest’s long-standing connection to the show, eventually pivoting to a breakdown of the latest entry in the Star Wars universe. The hosts analyze the movie as a reflection of the current state of the franchise, observing that while the film aims for entertainment, it feels hampered by a lack of narrative depth and world-building. They engage in a lively debate about the characterization of the Mandalorian, criticizing his perceived incompetence and lack of agency in the plot. The conversation also touches on the franchise's reliance on toy-ready character designs, specifically praising Grogu as an iconic addition despite the film’s overall boilerplate feel. Along the way, the panel critiques the film's "flat" script and its reliance on familiar tropes, while highlighting the fun, if somewhat jarring, presence of Sigourney Weaver. It is a quintessential, spirited discussion that captures the hosts' trademark blend of affection and exasperation for big-budget blockbusters.
FH Mini 152 - Birthday Movies
In this installment of The Flop House, host Dan McCoy leads his co-hosts, Stuart Wellington and Elliott Kalan, through a nostalgic and playful walk down memory lane. The episode focuses on the concept of birthday movies—specifically, the films that the hosts chose to see in theaters as children when trips to the cinema were rare, special occasions. Dan challenges Stuart and Elliott to guess a selection of his childhood birthday picks by providing clues based on production details, cast members, and infamous internet movie goofs. As they attempt to identify titles like Willow, Ghostbusters II, Gremlins 2, and What About Bob?, the hosts engage in lively debates about whether these films were truly worthy of a birthday outing. Along the way, they reflect on the cinematic landscape of the late 80s and early 90s, reminiscing about the blockbusters of that era and the varying experiences of growing up in families with different attitudes toward movie-going. The conversation serves as a humorous exploration of personal history, childhood film perception, and the enduring, sometimes questionable, nostalgia for the movies that defined their youth.
After Last Season, with J.D. Amato
In this episode of The Flop House, the hosts are joined by special guest J.D. Amato to discuss the notoriously baffling 2009 film After Last Season. Often cited as a singular piece of cinematic oddity, the movie gained a reputation as an urban legend due to its mysterious origins, lack of availability, and strange, dreamlike quality. The team explores the film’s unique production, which includes surreal digital effects, dialogue that feels untethered from reality, and an abundance of cutaway shots to walls and ceiling fans. Amato and the hosts analyze the movie’s bizarre directorial choices, which they playfully categorize as a form of "realism" that pushes the boundaries of the medium. They discuss how the film’s amateurish aesthetic—including an MRI machine fashioned from paper—creates a distancing effect that forces the audience to confront the artifice of the filmmaking process. Through their banter, the group dissects the experience of trying to follow a plot that seems to intentionally evade logic, ultimately turning a critical eye toward one of cinema’s most elusive and debated low-budget curiosities.
FH Mini #150 - Best Stephen King Movies
In this episode of The Flop House Mini, hosts Stuart Wellington, Dan McCoy, and Elliott Kalen embark on a mission to rank the best cinematic adaptations of Stephen King’s work. Acknowledging that King’s filmography is vast—ranging from iconic classics to obscure, direct-to-video titles—the hosts establish a process to narrow down the list. They adopt a somewhat ruthless approach, working backward through time to cut movies that do not merit a place in their definitive top ten, frequently debating the merits of various entries and their own personal nostalgia. Throughout the discussion, the hosts touch upon a wide array of titles, including The Shining, Misery, The Shawshank Redemption, and the myriad entries of the Children of the Corn series. The conversation balances genuine appreciation for certain films with lighthearted mockery of the more bizarre adaptations. As they whittle the selection down to a more manageable number, they pivot toward a more structured evaluation, assigning numerical ratings to the remaining contenders. It is a humorous, off-the-cuff deep dive into the hit-or-miss world of Stephen King’s massive screen legacy.
Ella McCay
FH Mini 147 - Mental Health Day
FH Mini 146 – Best of the Best (Pictures)
Related Podcasts
All podcast names and trademarks are the property of their respective owners. Podcasts listed on Podtastic are publicly available shows distributed via RSS. Podtastic does not endorse nor is endorsed by any podcast or podcast creator listed in this directory.