TH

The Peter Attia Drive

Peter Attia, MD

#380 ‒ The seed oil debate: are they uniquely harmful relative to other dietary fats? | Layne Norton, Ph.D.

Jan 19, 20262h 7m
Summary

In this episode of The Peter Attia Drive, nutrition scientist Layne Norton joins Peter Attia for an in-depth, evidence-based exploration of the controversial role of seed oils in the human diet. The discussion centers on whether these fats are uniquely harmful or if they can be part of a healthy nutritional framework. Layne and Peter examine the historical randomized controlled trials that fuel the debate, dissecting the nuances between different types of fats and their impact on cardiovascular disease. They navigate the complexities of LDL oxidation, the potential risks of industrial processing, and the validity of ancestral nutrition arguments. By contrasting the mechanistic biology of polyunsaturated versus saturated fats, the conversation helps listeners separate scientific evidence from popular rhetoric, ultimately providing a balanced perspective on how to prioritize dietary choices within the broader context of metabolic and long-term heart health.

Updated Apr 30, 2026

About This Episode

View the Show Notes Page for This Episode

Become a Member to Receive Exclusive Content

Sign Up to Receive Peter's Weekly Newsletter

Layne Norton is a nutrition scientist and accomplished power athlete,who returns to The Drive for a conversation that departs from the show's usual format. In this episode, Layne presents the evidence-based case that seed oils are not uniquely harmful under isocaloric conditions, while Peter steelmans the strongest versions of the opposing argument that seed oils are inherently harmful. They examine how scientific bias and evidence are evaluated, revisit the historical randomized controlled trials that shaped the seed oil controversy, and explore the mechanistic biology underlying LDL oxidation and atherosclerosis. Along the way, Layne unpacks the chemistry and processing of modern seed oils, assesses evolutionary and ancestral nutrition arguments, clarifies the relationship between seed oils, ultra-processed foods, and contemporary dietary patterns, and situates these questions within the larger context of lifestyle factors that drive cardiometabolic health. Layne concludes by offering practical considerations around dietary fats, cooking oils, and real-world food choices.

We discuss:

  • The idea behind this episode, biases, and evidence-based thinking [5:15];
  • The four core arguments behind claims that seed oils are harmful [12:30];
  • The Minnesota Coronary Experiment (MCE) [14:30];
  • The differences among saturated, monounsaturated, polyunsaturated, and trans fats, and why those differences matter for cardiovascular disease [18:30];
  • Missing trans fat data as a confounder in the Minnesota Coronary Experiment, other limitations of that study, and the challenge detecting meaningful differences in hard outcomes through nutrition research [24:00];
  • The Sydney Diet Heart Study (SDHS): an attempt to address the "duration problem" by enrolling a much higher-risk population [28:30];
  • Debating whether evidence from randomized trials supports the idea that seed oils are uniquely harmful once major confounders are removed [34:00];
  • The Rose Corn Oil trial: an often-cited study used to argue against polyunsaturated fats [36:30];
  • Three studies where replacing saturated fat with polyunsaturated fat produced different results than earlier trials [41:30];
  • Layne's explanation for why the evidence is pointing towards cardiovascular risk reduction when substituting polyunsaturated fat for saturated fat [47:30];
  • What Mendelian randomization says about the causal role of LDL cholesterol in ASCVD [56:45];
  • The compounding effects of life-long exposure to high LDL cholesterol [1:06:45];
  • Does the linoleic acid (omega-6) content of seed oils cause inflammation? [1:13:45];
  • Does the linoleic acid (omega-6) content of seed oils increase oxidized LDL? [1:19:30];
  • Layne's analogy to explain why lower LDL particle number outweighs higher per-particle oxidation risk when comparing polyunsaturated fats to saturated fats [1:26:15];
  • The role of oxidized LDL in CVD: exploring differences in a diet high in polyunsaturated fat (seed oils) versus high in saturated fat [1:28:00];
  • Examining whether industrial processing and solvent extraction of seed oils—especially residual hexane—could plausibly cause long-term harm [1:34:00];
  • The evolutionary and "ancestral diet" argument against seed oils [1:40:45];
  • Weighing concerns about industrial processing of seed oils against the totality of metabolic and cardiovascular evidence [1:47:30];
  • Practical considerations around dietary fats, cooking oils, and real-world food choices [1:50:00];
  • Comparing the health impact of seed oils with that of caloric intake and activity levels, and how to prioritize interventions [2:00:15];
  • More.

Connect With Peter on TwitterInstagramFacebook and YouTube

Listen to The Peter Attia Drive in Podtastic

For listeners, not advertisers

More Episodes

Building strength and muscle mass: how to optimize training, nutrition, and more for longevity (AMA #71 rebroadcast)

Jul 6, 20261h 44mSummary

In this episode of The Peter Attia Drive, Dr. Peter Attia presents a comprehensive overview of building strength and muscle mass, emphasizing their critical roles in longevity and healthspan. Originally aired as a subscriber-only AMA, this rebroadcast serves as a streamlined resource for listeners looking to understand the science behind physical training and its long-term benefits. The discussion highlights the vital distinction between muscle mass and muscle strength, noting that while both are important, strength is a more potent predictor of mortality. Attia explains why muscle acts as both a metabolic "sink" for glucose and an endocrine organ, providing protective effects against metabolic diseases and chronic inflammation. He also explores the concept of muscle as a protein reservoir, which is crucial for surviving periods of acute illness or surgery. Beyond the theory, the episode covers practical application, including the importance of grip strength as a health marker, the necessity of progressive overload, and the value of explosive power training for aging populations. Attia also addresses nutritional requirements, such as adequate protein intake, and discusses the importance of consistency and recovery in long-term exercise programming.

#398 ‒ AMA #86: GLP-1 RAs and muscle loss: new data, better questions, and how to preserve muscle during weight loss

Jun 29, 20269 minSummary

In this episode of The Drive, Peter Attia dives into the complex relationship between GLP-1 receptor agonists—such as Ozempic, Wegovy, and Zepbound—and body composition. The discussion centers on the growing concern regarding the loss of lean mass during rapid weight loss, a phenomenon that has garnered significant attention as these medications become more prevalent. Attia explores the accuracy of using DEXA scans to measure lean mass and emphasizes that the clinical definition of lean mass can often be misleading, particularly when evaluating physical function and strength. The conversation moves beyond simple weight loss statistics to address how these drugs influence bone density, fracture risk, and different fat depots across the body. Attia addresses common fears surrounding muscle atrophy while highlighting the importance of proper patient counseling regarding nutrition and resistance training. By differentiating between clinical trial averages and real-world outcomes, he illustrates how modifiable behaviors can significantly mitigate risks. The episode also provides a forward-looking perspective on emerging drugs like retatrutide, framing the conversation around how patients can safely maintain muscle and bone health while undergoing medical weight management.

#397 ‒ Endometriosis and adenomyosis: diagnosis, fertility, reproductive aging, and emerging treatments | Renato Tomioka, M.D., Ph.D.

Jun 22, 20261h 58mSummary

In this episode, Dr. Renato Tomioka, a leading expert in reproductive medicine and gynecologic surgery, provides an in-depth exploration of endometriosis and adenomyosis, two prevalent yet frequently overlooked conditions. He clarifies the distinct pathologies of these diseases: endometriosis involves endometrial-like tissue outside the uterus, while adenomyosis occurs when this tissue invades the muscular wall of the uterus. Dr. Tomioka emphasizes that both conditions are often misunderstood and misdiagnosed, leading to a typical diagnostic delay of five to twelve years. He explains that modern shifts in reproductive patterns—such as the increased number of ovulatory cycles in a woman's lifetime compared to previous centuries—may be contributing to their rising prevalence. The conversation covers the diagnostic transition from invasive surgical laparoscopy toward specialized ultrasound and MRI, highlighting the importance of early intervention to prevent central pain sensitization. The discussion further extends to the intersections between these conditions, infertility, and reproductive aging. Dr. Tomioka outlines the nuances of treatment, including the complex decision-making process between hormonal therapies and surgery, while providing crucial insights into how female age and chromosomal quality impact long-term fertility outcomes.

#396 ‒ Breast cancer screening: understanding risk, deciding when to start and how often to screen, and choosing the right imaging strategy

Jun 15, 202650 minSummary

In this episode of The Drive, the host explores the complexities of breast cancer screening, addressing why many women remain confused about guidelines and why mortality rates persist despite the availability of effective tools. The discussion centers on moving beyond generic population-level recommendations to create a personalized screening strategy that maximizes an individual's chances of early detection. The episode emphasizes that while mammography is the foundation of screening, it is not a one-size-fits-all solution. Key insights include the critical importance of performing formal risk assessments by age 25, understanding the impact of breast density, and recognizing that risk factors—including genetics, family history, and ancestry—must be evaluated holistically. The host explains the hierarchy of imaging, noting that for high-risk individuals, mammography alone is often insufficient and should be supplemented with more sensitive tools like breast MRI or contrast-enhanced mammography. Ultimately, the host argues that screening should be a deliberate, personalized process. By weighing the benefit of early detection against the potential for false positives and diagnostic anxiety, women can make informed decisions to optimize their screening protocols, ensuring the best possible outcome for their specific health profile.

#395 - Brain lipidology: understanding APOE, cholesterol homeostasis, Alzheimer's disease risk, and the effects of lipid-lowering therapies on brain health | Tom Dayspring, M.D.

Jun 8, 20261h 40mSummary

In this episode of The Drive, host Peter Attia welcomes back renowned lipidologist Dr. Tom Dayspring for a technical, deep-dive discussion on the complex relationship between lipidology and brain health. The conversation begins by establishing a baseline understanding of cholesterol transport in the periphery, clearly distinguishing how the body utilizes ApoB-containing lipoproteins and HDL to manage cholesterol. A primary focus of the episode is the brain's unique cholesterol system, which operates almost entirely independently of the rest of the body. Dr. Dayspring explains why the blood-brain barrier prevents peripheral lipoproteins from entering the brain, emphasizing that the brain synthesizes its own cholesterol to support the massive requirements of myelin and cellular integrity. The discussion further explores the role of the APOE genotype in Alzheimer’s disease risk, specifically examining the potential links between cholesterol homeostasis, amyloid plaques, and tau proteins. Finally, the pair addresses the nuances of lipid-lowering therapies—including statins and omega-3 fatty acids—and clarifies common misconceptions regarding the risks and benefits of lowering LDL cholesterol for neurodegenerative disease prevention. It is a vital, evidence-based conversation for those seeking to understand the intricate interplay between cardiovascular health and long-term brain function.

#394 ‒ Sleep pharmacology: the role of medications in healthy sleep, the promise of emerging therapies, and the evidence for common sleep supplements

Jun 1, 202654 minSummary

In this episode of The Drive, Peter Attia explores the complex world of sleep pharmacology, moving beyond basic sleep hygiene to examine how medications interact with the biological mechanisms of sleep. He identifies four primary drivers of sleep issues: homeostatic sleep pressure, circadian timing, hyper-arousal, and sleep architecture. Attia emphasizes that behavioral interventions remain the gold standard, but he argues that when medications are necessary, they must be precisely matched to the specific underlying problem rather than used as blunt, long-term crutches. The discussion provides a detailed analysis of three major classes of sleep aids: benzodiazepines, Z-drugs, and dual orexin receptor antagonists (DORAs). Attia explains how each class affects brain chemistry, noting the risks of dependence, cognitive impairment, and fragmented sleep architecture associated with traditional sedatives. A highlight of the conversation is the emerging research on DORAs, which function by dampening the brain's wakefulness drive rather than forcing sedation. Attia discusses the promising, albeit preliminary, evidence that this specific mechanism might support glymphatic waste clearance—a vital process for brain health—potentially offering a new dimension in the conversation regarding sleep and neurodegenerative disease prevention.

#393 ‒ AMA #85: A guide to medications and supplements: determining what to take, what to skip, and how to know if they're working for you

May 25, 202613 minSummary

In this episode of The Peter Attia Drive, Peter Attia addresses the common pitfalls individuals encounter when navigating the complex world of medications and supplements. He argues that most people approach these interventions incorrectly by focusing on the "what" rather than the "why." Attia emphasizes that before considering any intervention, one must clearly define the problem using specific, actionable metrics, clear thresholds, and defined time horizons. Without this framework, he warns, it is easy to fall into the trap of subjective storytelling and placebo effects. The discussion further categorizes interventions into four distinct "jobs": disease treatment, symptom relief, risk reduction, and optimization. Attia explains that the evidence threshold and risk tolerance should shift significantly depending on which category a supplement or medication falls into. He cautions listeners to be particularly skeptical of "optimization" interventions, which often lack rigorous evidence and rely on vague mechanistic claims. By stressing the importance of evaluating the counterfactual—what would happen if no action were taken—Attia provides a practical, evidence-based approach to help listeners make more informed, objective decisions about their health.

#392 - Genetic testing: when it's valuable, how to choose the right test, and what to do with the results

May 18, 20261h 2mSummary

In this episode of The Peter Attia Drive, the host explores the complex and often misunderstood world of genetic testing. Peter Attia builds a practical framework for listeners to evaluate whether genetic testing is truly useful, emphasizing that many tests are probabilistic rather than deterministic. He cautions that while some results can be life-changing, others provide little actionable data, often serving as a poor substitute for direct phenotypic assessment through blood work, imaging, and clinical history. The discussion navigates the four major disease categories—cardiovascular, metabolic, cancer, and neurodegenerative conditions—to highlight where genetics offer genuine clinical value versus where they are oversold. Attia distinguishes between common, lower-impact genetic variants and high-penetrance mutations, such as those related to hereditary cancer syndromes or rare monogenic disorders. A significant portion of the episode is dedicated to the psychological impact of these results and the necessity of asking specific questions before testing, such as whether a result will meaningfully change a patient's behavior or clinical care. Ultimately, the episode encourages listeners to prioritize clarity over curiosity and to ensure that genetic testing is used as a precise tool rather than a speculative crystal ball for future health.

#389 - Thinking scientifically: why it's hard, why it matters, and a practical toolkit

Apr 27, 202653 minSummary

In this episode of The Peter Attia Drive, Peter examines the foundational principles of scientific thinking and why it remains an essential yet challenging skill in the modern era. He explores the cognitive biases and evolutionary instincts that often hinder objective reasoning, making it difficult to distinguish evidence from personal belief in an age of rampant misinformation. Listeners will learn how to navigate uncertainty, differentiate between scientific knowledge and mathematical proof, and understand why updating one’s views in light of new evidence is a sign of intellectual strength. The episode provides a comprehensive, practical toolkit for improving decision-making, including techniques to identify bias, evaluate expert credibility, and challenge personal assumptions. By the end of the discussion, listeners gain a structured framework designed to foster more disciplined, effective, and evidence-based thinking in their daily lives.

#388 — Prostate cancer screening: why current PSA guidelines are failing men and how modern tools improve early detection and save lives

Apr 20, 202646 minSummary

In this episode of The Peter Attia Drive, Peter Attia conducts a thorough examination of prostate cancer screening, addressing the concerning rise in advanced and metastatic diagnoses. He argues that current clinical guidelines are failing men and explores how modern diagnostic tools can reverse these trends. Listeners will learn why a single PSA value is insufficient and why tracking PSA velocity and density over time, combined with MRI imaging, offers a more accurate approach to detection. The discussion also covers the critical role of active surveillance in preventing overtreatment, the limitations of historical clinical trials used to discourage screening, and the importance of accounting for medications like finasteride that can mask warning signs. Ultimately, Attia presents a compelling, data-driven case for proactive, refined screening strategies as a necessary path toward eliminating prostate cancer mortality.

All podcast names and trademarks are the property of their respective owners. Podcasts listed on Podtastic are publicly available shows distributed via RSS. Podtastic does not endorse nor is endorsed by any podcast or podcast creator listed in this directory.