The Prosecutors

Summary

Step into the courtroom of the mind with The Prosecutors, a true crime podcast that trades sensationalism for the cold, hard logic of the legal system. Hosted by Alice and Brett, this show offers a distinctively analytical approach to some of history’s most baffling cold cases, tragic massacres, and mysterious disappearances. Drawing on their professional experience as prosecutors, the duo meticulously dismantles official narratives, highlighting how systemic failures, regulatory lapses, and investigative bias often obscure the truth. Whether they are scrutinizing the suspicious circumstances surrounding the 1979 Ghost Train fire, dissecting the forensic evidence in modern mass shootings, or questioning the convenient legends of mid-century lawmen, Alice and Brett are obsessed with the details. They excel at identifying the disconnect between what was reported and what the evidence actually says, providing a necessary layer of skepticism to high-profile cases. The show doesn't just recount events; it explores the "why" behind the evidence, challenging listeners to think critically about how tragedies are documented and remembered. Beyond the deep dives into grim mysteries, the podcast also offers a humanizing perspective, frequently centering the victims and their stories rather than the perpetrators. And when the weight of the cases gets too heavy, the After Dark episodes allow the hosts to pull back the curtain, sharing candid, humorous stories that reveal the people behind the legal analysis. It is an essential listen for anyone who demands more than just a surface-level story.

Updated Jul 7, 2026