Series 5: Case 5: The Goth Poltergeist

Cold Cases: Episode 13: Case Update

Jun 30, 202641 minSummary

In this special bonus episode of Uncanny: Cold Cases, host Danny Robbins reunites with forensic psychologist Dr. Kiran O’Keefe and parapsychologist Evelyn Hollow to revisit the most provocative stories from the series. The panel digs into listener feedback, fresh leads, and alternative theories regarding some of the show’s most infamous investigations. The episode revisits the violent haunting at 30 East Drive, exploring both the psychological toll on the Pritchard family and historical theories—such as residual echoes from the English Civil War or the effects of local licorice consumption on perception. The discussion then pivots to the mysterious Spring-Heeled Jack, examining new witness accounts that place the entity as recently as 1997, and comparing the phenomenon to global occurrences like the Grease Devil crisis in Sri Lanka. Finally, the hosts address the unsettling Sandown Clown, clarifying their commitment to authentic source testimony. Throughout the episode, O’Keefe and Hollow continue their classic debate, balancing skeptical explanations—such as parkour or mass hysteria—against the lingering, unexplained mysteries that define the Uncanny community’s enduring fascination with the paranormal.

Cold Cases: Case 12: Borley Rectory Part 2

Jun 23, 202630 minSummary

In this second part of the Borley Rectory investigation, the Uncanny team dives deeper into the chaotic and increasingly dangerous residence of the Reverend Lionel Foyster and his wife, Marianne. As the paranormal activity intensifies—manifesting as physical attacks, flying objects, and mysterious scrawled messages—the hosts and their experts, parapsychologist Evelyn Hollow and skeptic Dr. Ciarán O'Keeffe, debate the validity of these claims. The discussion centers on the controversial figure of Marianne, exploring whether she was a victim of genuine hauntings or if she was staging events to gain attention or deflect from personal secrets. The episode chronicles the arrival of renowned ghost hunter Harry Price, who initially attempts to debunk the activity as fraud. The narrative follows the house’s descent into legend, marked by the arrival of spiritualists, the eventual destruction of the building by fire, and the lingering mystery surrounding physical evidence found on the site. Ultimately, the discussion highlights the difficulty of separating historical fact from sensationalism, leaving listeners to weigh the possibility of supernatural phenomena against human intervention in one of history’s most famous haunted locations.

Cold Cases: Case 11: Borley Rectory

Jun 16, 202629 minSummary

In this episode of Uncanny, host Danny Robbins delves into the chilling and controversial history of Borley Rectory, famously dubbed the most haunted house in England. Joined by forensic psychologist Dr. Chris French and parapsychologist Evelyn Hollow, the team explores the multifaceted lore surrounding the property, which ranges from spectral nuns and headless horsemen to violent poltergeist activity. The discussion traces the building’s history from its construction in the 1860s through the unsettling experiences of the Bull family and the subsequent arrival of the Reverend Eric Smith and his wife. The hosts analyze the tension between legitimate paranormal phenomena and the possibility of elaborate hoaxes, environmental factors, or local mischief. A significant portion of the episode focuses on Harry Price, the legendary ghost hunter whose investigative methods and sensationalized reporting helped cement Borley Rectory’s place in folklore. Through a mix of historical accounts and expert analysis, the episode invites listeners to consider whether the rectory was truly a nexus of supernatural energy or simply a site defined by psychological projection, structural decay, and the power of a persistent, self-fulfilling legend.

Cold Cases: Case 10: The Great Amherst Mystery

Jun 9, 202628 minSummary

In this episode of Uncanny: Cold Cases, host Danny Robbins explores one of the most famous and unsettling paranormal accounts in North American history: the 1879 haunting of Esther Cox in Amherst, Nova Scotia. Joined by skeptic Dr. Ciaran O’Keeffe and parapsychologist Evelyn Hollow, Robbins examines the harrowing experiences of eighteen-year-old Esther, who was plagued by phantom bangs, spontaneous fires, and physical attacks. The discussion delves into whether these occurrences were genuine supernatural phenomena or a manifestation of extreme psychological distress. The hosts analyze the potential link between Esther’s traumatic history—specifically a near-violent encounter with a local man—and the subsequent activity in her home. A major focal point is the investigation by Walter Hubble, a self-proclaimed debunker who was reportedly converted to a believer after living with the family. The panel weighs the evidence of physical manifestations, such as knives flying through the air and matches appearing out of thin air, against theories of illness, trauma-induced hysteria, or deliberate manipulation. Ultimately, the episode challenges listeners to consider the human cost of these events, as Esther’s life remained marked by hardship long after the poltergeist activity faded.

Cold Cases: Case 9: The South Shields Poltergeist Part Two

Jun 2, 202628 minSummary

In the second part of the investigation into the South Shields Poltergeist, host Danny Robbins and his guests, parapsychologist Evelyn Hollow and forensic psychologist Dr. Kirina O'Keeffe, return to the harrowing events at 42 Lock Street. The family remains under siege by phenomena that have escalated to include physical attacks, bizarrely manipulated objects, and menacing text messages sent from a battery-removed phone. The episode delves into the investigators' attempts to document the activity, including a chilling scene where toys are found arranged in a threatening tableau. As the team considers theories like poltergeist contagion and electromagnetic field interference, they discuss the psychological and physical toll on the family. A breakthrough occurs when a consultant suggests the entity may be drawing energy from electrical items, leading to a complete power-down of the home, which appears to halt the activity. However, the episode concludes with a final, unsettling coda: witnesses observing an unexplained, human-like figure present with the family, suggesting the mystery may run deeper than simple electrical anomalies. The episode highlights the tension between skeptical explanations and the reality of the family's terror.

Cold Cases: Case 8: The South Shields Poltergeist Part 1

May 26, 202628 minSummary

In this episode of Uncanny: Cold Cases, host Danny Robbins delves into a chilling and exceptionally well-documented poltergeist haunting that took place in South Shields, England, in 2005. The story follows a young couple, Marianne and Mark, and their toddler, Robert, who find themselves terrorized by an unseen force in their home. What begins with small, eerie occurrences—such as a shower turning on by itself and mugs tipping over—quickly escalates into physical manifestations, including furniture being rearranged and a rocking horse repeatedly moving to impossible locations. Robbins is joined by paranormal investigators Evelyn Hollow and Dr. Ciarán O’Keeffe to analyze the phenomena. They explore the terrifying introduction of an imaginary friend named Sammy and a mysterious man seen by the child, alongside instances of physical harm and aggressive telecommunications, such as menacing text messages appearing on phones with their batteries removed. The episode highlights the unique challenges of a modern haunting, balancing skeptical inquiry—examining potential environmental causes or psychological factors—against the unsettling evidence that suggests an intelligent, malevolent presence. As the activity reaches a threatening level, the team prepares to explore the mystery further in part two.

Cold Cases: Case 7: Spring-heeled Jack

May 19, 202627 minSummary

In this episode of Uncanny, host Danny Robins investigates the chilling cold case of Spring-heeled Jack, a legendary figure who terrorized Victorian London starting in 1837. Described by witnesses as a terrifying, seemingly supernatural assailant with glowing red eyes, razor-sharp metal claws, and the ability to leap over buildings, the entity left a trail of fear and physical harm across the city. The investigation explores the conflicting perspectives of forensic psychologist Kia O'Keeffe and parapsychologist Evelyn Hollow. While the team discusses potential rational explanations—such as elite pranksters, copycats, or the use of chemical devices to simulate fire-breathing—they also examine the unsettling physical evidence that complicates a purely skeptical view. The discussion touches upon the social dynamics of the time, the potential link between these attacks and later criminal legends, and the eerie, recurring nature of the sightings that persisted for decades. By analyzing witness accounts and historical context, the hosts delve into whether Spring-heeled Jack was a singular human predator, a manifestation of collective fear, or something more enigmatic that continues to defy traditional classification.

Series 5: Case 10: The Priest Hole

Series 5: Case 9: Christmas Casebook with Diane Morgan

Series 5: Case 8: Revenants and Revelations