#179 - 2027 Pilgrimage to France with Fr. Kenneth Parsad

#182 - Reimagining the Mass

May 26, 202618 minSummary

In this episode of Why Catholic, host Justin Hibbert launches a new series dedicated to reimagining the Catholic Mass. Drawing an analogy between the immersive, devoted fandom of popular fantasy epics like Star Wars, The Lord of the Rings, and The Chronicles of Narnia, Hibbert argues that Catholics should approach the Mass with a similar sense of wonder and imaginative engagement. He suggests that, much like the wardrobe in Narnia serving as a portal to another realm, the church is a place where heaven and earth intersect. Hibbert challenges the notion that the Mass is merely a routine ritual or a cognitive exercise. Instead, he highlights the Jewish concept of remembrance, which seeks to transcend time, allowing the faithful to be mystically present at the Last Supper and the Crucifixion. By contrasting rigid, rule-based religious instruction with the transformative power of the true story of Christ, Hibbert encourages listeners to activate their imagination. He concludes that the Mass is not just a service to attend, but an eternal, supernatural reality in which every participant is called to play a vital part.

#181 - Why Catholic and Not Eastern Orthodox?

May 19, 202629 minSummary

In this episode of Why Catholic, host Justin Hibbert explores a common dilemma for those journeying from evangelicalism toward ancient Christianity: the choice between the Catholic Church and Eastern Orthodoxy. Recognizing that both traditions share valid apostolic succession and a sacramental worldview, Hibbert addresses why so many converts find the Eastern Orthodox path more palatable, often citing an ingrained anti-Catholic bias that permeates modern Protestantism. Drawing on his own experience and extensive historical study, Hibbert argues that the Catholic Church is the true home of the historic faith. He provides a detailed deep dive into early church history, tracing the development of the major patriarchates and the frequent councils held to combat internal heresies. A central theme is the preeminence of the Bishop of Rome, which Hibbert asserts has been foundational from the beginning, supported by the writings of Saint Irenaeus. He critically examines the history of conflicts between Rome and Constantinople, specifically pointing to figures like Photius and Mark of Ephesus. Ultimately, Hibbert concludes that while the Eastern Church has struggled with internal division and resistance to unified authority, the Catholic Church offers a unique, cohesive structure that truly fulfills the call to unity among Christians.

#180 - The Ascension

May 17, 202616 minSummary

In this episode of Why Catholic, host Justin Hibbert explores the theological significance of the Ascension, examining why Jesus departed from his disciples forty days after the Resurrection. The discussion moves beyond the historical narrative to address why this event was a necessary part of the human experience of Christ. Hibbert argues that by ascending into heaven, Jesus completed his earthly mission, prepared a place for his followers, and cleared the way for the coming of the Holy Spirit. The episode also highlights the profound connections between the life of Jesus and the Levitical calendar, framing his death, resurrection, and ascension within the context of ancient Jewish feasts. By drawing parallels to events in the Book of Exodus—such as the giving of the law at Mount Sinai—the host illuminates the intentionality behind the timing of these sacred events. Ultimately, the episode serves as an invitation for listeners to see how the Old Covenant serves as a precursor to the New, showcasing a divine plan that intertwines history with spiritual fulfillment.

#178 - When Protestant Clergy Become Catholic

May 5, 202621 minSummary

In this episode of Why Catholic, host Justin Hibbert explores the unique and often challenging journey of Protestant clergy who choose to convert to Catholicism. Reflecting on his own background as a former Baptist pastor, Hibbert discusses the profound professional and personal sacrifices these individuals face, including the sudden loss of their livelihood, social isolation from former congregations, and the complex process of shifting their theological worldview. Drawing on insights from the second annual clergy convert conference, the host highlights how these converts frequently become effective Catholic apologists, driven by the intense research they conducted to justify their transitions. Hibbert emphasizes the importance of patience and humility as converts navigate their new identities within the Church, noting that they often feel socially disoriented after leaving behind roles of leadership. The episode concludes with practical advice for both parishes and laypeople on how to welcome and support these individuals, encouraging them to find meaningful ways to serve within their new faith communities. This episode provides an empathetic look at the intersection of professional experience, spiritual conviction, and the search for belonging after a major life transition.