AM

Americast

BBC News

The Democrats fight back Trump-style in Maine… but have they messed up?

Jun 11, 202639 min
Summary

In this episode of Americast, the hosts examine a high-stakes political experiment unfolding in Maine, a state that could determine which party controls the U.S. Senate following the upcoming midterms. The discussion centers on the Democratic candidate for Senate, Graham Platner, an unconventional choice described as an oyster fisherman and military veteran with no prior political experience. The hosts explore the significant controversy surrounding Platner, whose campaign has been marred by revelations of past social media posts, a former Nazi tattoo, and allegations regarding his treatment of women. While these issues have sparked intense debate about his viability, some Democratic strategists and supporters view him as a necessary departure from the traditional political establishment. Proponents argue that his “redemption arc” and authentic, non-politician background could resonate with voters looking for a change. However, the hosts question whether this gamble will pay off or ultimately alienate voters, especially when running against the long-serving incumbent, Susan Collins. The episode provides a fascinating look at the complexities of candidate vetting, the evolving strategies of grassroots political movements, and the risks inherent in bypassing traditional party institutions to capture a seat of such national importance.

Updated Jul 5, 2026

About This Episode

There are new allegations against Graham Platner, the confirmed Democratic senate candidate in Maine. The small north eastern state which borders Canada is at the centre of a fierce debate within the Democratic party. Have they picked the right candidate for a profoundly important election in Maine, which will be integral to Democrats’ chances of winning back control of the US Senate?

Graham Platner, the Democrat’s new candidate, is facing multiple allegations and scandals around his conduct and behaviour, particularly around women. He says he’s been unfairly targeted, and that everyone has behaviours in their past which they regret. But will that be enough to convince voters? In this episode, Anthony Zurcher - who is just back from reporting in Maine - joins Justin to give us his take after hearing from voters and Graham Platner himself.

Also, we hear from insiders on exactly how Platner was selected and vetted before he became a Democrat candidate. He’ll be facing incumbent Susan Collins, the longest serving female Republican in the senate, who is also a longstanding Trump critic.

Plus, with accusations from the US president about election fraud in California - where ballots are still being counted for the governor race to replace Democrat Gavin Newsom - we look at the preliminary results. It looks like British-born Republican Steve Hilton has been chosen to stand against Democrat Xavier Baccera in November. Why is it taking so long to count ballots and come up with a result? And, we discuss whether Trump’s claims about election fraud part of a bigger playbook for November’s midterm elections.

HOSTS: • Justin Webb, Radio 4 presenter • Anthony Zurcher, North America Correspondent

GET IN TOUCH: • Join our online community: https://discord.gg/qSrxqNcmRB • Send us a message or voice note via WhatsApp to +44 330 123 9480 • Email Americast@bbc.co.uk • Or use #Americast

This episode was made by Tom Gillett, Alix Pickles and Ellie House. The technical producer was Jonny Baker. The series producer is Purvee Pattni. The senior news editor is Sam Bonham.

If you want to be notified every time we publish a new episode, please subscribe to us on BBC Sounds by hitting the subscribe button on the app.

You can now listen to Americast on a smart speaker. If you want to listen, just say "Ask BBC Sounds to play Americast”. It works on most smart speakers.

US Election Unspun: Sign up for Anthony’s BBC newsletter: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-68093155

Americast is part of the BBC News Podcasts family of podcasts. The team that makes Americast also makes lots of other podcasts, including Newscast. If you enjoy Americast (and if you're reading this then you hopefully do), then we think that you will enjoy some of our other pods too. See links below.

Newscast: https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/series/p05299nl Top Comment: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m001mssm Radical: https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/brand/p0gg4k6r The Global Story: https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/brand/w13xtvsd

Listen to Americast in Podtastic

For listeners, not advertisers

More Episodes

After 250 years, do US citizens still believe in the American Dream?

Jul 3, 202623 minSummary

In this episode of Americast, the hosts sit down with historian Heather Cox Richardson to mark the upcoming 250th anniversary of the United States. They explore the country’s journey since 1776, debating whether the American experiment has been a success or a failure. Richardson emphasizes that the nation’s history is defined by a constant, inherent tension between those who prioritize the protection of property and those who advocate for equality and the rights of the governed. The conversation delves into the current state of American politics, addressing voter disillusionment, legislative gridlock, and the ideological shifts that have moved the Republican Party away from historical norms. Despite the significant political polarization and the challenges facing modern democracy, Richardson argues that the American people still possess a fundamental capacity for agency and civic renewal. Rather than viewing democracy as a finished product, the participants discuss it as an ongoing, imperfect project. The episode concludes with a reflection on how local celebrations of the Fourth of July continue to ground the American identity, suggesting that the search for the country’s true meaning remains a vital and evolving process for citizens.

Have Republicans been given a major midterms boost by the Supreme Court?

Jul 1, 202635 minSummary

In this episode of Americast, the hosts examine the significant political and legal ramifications of recent Supreme Court rulings. A primary focus is the court’s decision to remove limits on coordinated spending between political candidates and parties. The hosts analyze how this shift effectively dismantles the last vestiges of the 2002 McCain-Feingold campaign finance reforms. They discuss the potential for this ruling to empower political parties and boost Republican candidates, who currently hold a significant financial advantage over the Democratic Party. The conversation also covers the Supreme Court’s refusal to overturn birthright citizenship, a decision that maintains established constitutional interpretations despite personal efforts by Donald Trump to challenge the policy. Furthermore, the hosts explore the court's ruling regarding transgender athletes, which allows states to implement bans on transgender women competing in female sports categories. The discussion highlights how this topic remains a potent wedge issue, one that tends to unite the Republican base while creating significant internal friction and messaging challenges for the Democratic Party. Throughout the episode, the hosts assess how these judicial developments are likely to shape the electoral landscape and influence future campaign strategies.

Has the Supreme Court just made Trump the most powerful president in history?

Jun 29, 202627 minSummary

In this episode of Americast, the hosts examine a series of pivotal Supreme Court rulings and their implications for the balance of power in the United States. The discussion centers on a significant decision regarding independent regulatory agencies, where the Court ruled that the President has broad authority to remove heads of commissions like the Federal Trade Commission. Legal experts argue that this shift represents a substantial endorsement of the unitary executive theory, granting the White House unprecedented control over regulatory bodies that were previously shielded from political interference. While the ruling was a clear win for presidential authority, the hosts and guest Kate Shaw note that the Court displayed a more nuanced approach in other cases. For instance, justices maintained protections for the Federal Reserve and allowed states to continue accepting mail-in ballots postmarked by election day, surprising many observers. Throughout the episode, the team analyzes these decisions to determine if the Supreme Court acts as a rubber stamp for Donald Trump or if it maintains essential guardrails. They conclude that while the Court is increasingly empowering the presidency, it remains an unpredictable institution that occasionally defies the former president’s expectations.

How can Democrats persuade more voters to like them? (with Ben Rhodes, Obama’s former senior advisor)

Jun 26, 202642 minSummary

In this episode of Americast, hosts interview Ben Rhodes, a former senior advisor to Barack Obama, to explore the future of the Democratic Party and how it can effectively connect with a broader swath of American voters. Rhodes argues that the left has struggled to counter right-wing messaging, partly because it has failed to build the same kind of robust media ecosystems and cultural influence that conservatives have established over the last decade. A major theme of the conversation is the necessity for Democrats to embrace authenticity and vulnerability. Rhodes criticizes modern political communication for being overly cautious, jargon-heavy, and disconnected from the everyday concerns of the working class. He reflects on key historical speeches, including Obama’s landmark address on race in 2008, to highlight how personal, nuanced storytelling can bridge divides and build a multiracial coalition. He suggests that Democrats often fall into the trap of being too "grim" or "angry," arguing instead for a more joyful and fearless political approach. Ultimately, Rhodes emphasizes that voters are looking for genuine connection and leadership that stands for something tangible, urging the party to move past safe political talking points to foster a shared sense of American identity.

Can Trump convince Republicans he’s won the war on Iran?

Jun 24, 202632 minSummary

In this episode of Americast, the hosts examine the complex political landscape surrounding Donald Trump’s recent memorandum of understanding with Iran. While Trump frames the agreement as a victory that promises to de-escalate tensions and lower oil prices, the hosts explore the significant skepticism it has triggered across the political spectrum. Many Republicans, including prominent hawks, remain wary of lifting sanctions before securing concrete nuclear inspections or addressing Iran’s regional influence and ballistic missile program. The discussion also highlights the friction within the Republican Party, exemplified by a recent symbolic War Powers Act vote where several GOP senators broke ranks. The hosts analyze how Trump is attempting to navigate this political liability by shifting blame to oil companies for slow price drops and promising that Iran will use newly available funds to purchase American agricultural products. Finally, the episode shifts to the Democratic primary results in New York, where the success of several democratic socialist candidates suggests an internal shift that could pose new electoral challenges for the party establishment, providing Republicans with fresh campaign ammunition ahead of the midterms.

Americanswers… Why has JD Vance changed his mind about Trump's intelligence?

Jun 22, 202631 minSummary

In this episode of Americast, the hosts tackle a series of listener questions that highlight the complexities and paradoxes of the current political climate in the United States. The discussion begins with an unusual but symbolic controversy: the deteriorating condition of the White House reflecting pool. What started as an attempt at renovation has turned into a public spectacle of green algae and peeling paint, which the team identifies as a poignant metaphor for the broader challenges and administrative struggles characterizing the current presidency. The hosts also delve into JD Vance’s recent public remarks regarding Donald Trump’s intelligence. They analyze the political calculations behind Vance’s decision to praise Trump’s IQ, suggesting that such rhetoric serves as both a strategic alignment with the president and an attempt to justify Vance’s own shifting political stance. Additionally, the episode covers the escalating tensions between the U.S. and its international allies, specifically the public spat with Italy’s Georgia Meloni. The team reflects on how global leaders are increasingly moving away from diplomatic deference toward more confrontational stances as they re-evaluate the utility of their alliances with the Trump administration.

Elon Musk the trillionaire... does the global economy need him to succeed?

Jun 19, 202623 minSummary

In this episode of Americast, the hosts explore the meteoric rise of Elon Musk as the world’s first trillionaire and examine the implications of his expansive, science-fiction-inspired business strategy. The discussion focuses on SpaceX’s recent initial public offering and how its massive valuation reflects a global gamble on Musk’s ability to turn futuristic concepts—such as orbital AI data centers and interplanetary colonization—into reality. Investigative reporter Ryan Mack joins the program to break down the complexities of Musk’s financial control, noting that investors are essentially buying into an unproven vision where Musk maintains an 82% voting majority. The episode draws parallels between current AI-driven market trends and historical boom-and-bust cycles, like the dot-com era or the expansion of the railways. The hosts and their guest analyze the potential risks to the U.S. and global economies should these ambitious tech bets fail to materialize. Ultimately, the conversation highlights a tension between the inspiration Musk provides as an innovator and the reality of the market’s reliance on his unpredictable, high-stakes promises, questioning what a potential correction could mean for pension funds and the broader financial landscape.

Jill Biden reveals how she really felt about Joe Biden’s health whilst he was president

Jun 17, 202629 minSummary

In this episode of Americast, the hosts explore a range of topics that bridge the gap between human interest stories and the complexities of American politics. The discussion begins with the viral social media phenomenon surrounding international football fans visiting the United States. The hosts highlight the genuine warmth and cultural exchanges occurring between local communities and visiting teams, noting how these heartwarming interactions often contrast with the harsher rhetoric frequently found in the online political sphere. Transitioning to domestic politics, the podcast examines Jill Biden’s recent media appearances regarding her new book. The hosts analyze her candid remarks about the infamous presidential debate from two years ago, specifically her admission that she feared for her husband’s health at the time. This segment sparks a broader discussion on the risks of reopening past wounds within the Democratic party and the potential impact of such disclosures on political narratives. Finally, the team shifts to the Department of Justice, breaking down the nomination of Todd Blanche as Attorney General and the implications of appointing a former personal defense attorney to such a powerful role, while concluding with a lighthearted look at listener contributions about the state of Colorado.

Americanswers… on 5 Live! Is Trump still fit for the job on his 80th birthday?

Jun 15, 202635 minSummary

In this episode of Americast, the hosts examine the implications of Donald Trump’s recent birthday celebration, which featured a high-profile UFC event on the White House grounds. The discussion highlights the stark partisan divide surrounding the event, exploring how such displays are intentionally designed to provoke reactions and engage specific voter bases, particularly younger men. The conversation shifts to the global stage, with a critical look at the status of the Iran deal and the logistical challenges facing the G7 as leaders attempt to stabilize the economy and navigate the complexities of international relations. The hosts also address listener questions regarding Donald Trump’s fitness for office as he becomes the second-oldest president in U.S. history, contrasting the transparency of his media interactions with the guarded approach of his predecessor. Finally, the podcast turns to the future of the Democratic Party by analyzing Senator Jon Ossoff. The hosts evaluate his appeal as a potential presidential candidate for 2028, noting his ability to combine sharp political oratory with bipartisan legislative achievements, while also discussing the strategic risks his departure from the Senate could pose for the Democratic majority.

The battle in rural America against AI data centres

Jun 12, 202638 minSummary

In this episode of Americast, the hosts explore the growing grassroots resistance to the construction of massive AI data centers across rural America. While these facilities are touted as engines for future technological and economic growth, their physical presence—often occupying vast amounts of land—is triggering significant pushback from local communities. The discussion highlights that opposition is not limited to traditional environmentalists; instead, it spans the political spectrum. Residents are expressing deep concerns over the heavy resource demands of these centers, specifically regarding strained water supplies and surging electricity costs. Furthermore, the episode examines the potential impact on property values and the loss of local quality of life. Energy journalist Robert Bryce joins the conversation to provide data on the surge in project rejections, noting that local citizens are finding ways to challenge Big Tech at the zoning level when they feel they have no other platform to voice their grievances. Ultimately, the hosts discuss the complex political dilemma facing leaders: balancing the massive capital investment and economic promise of the AI revolution against the palpable frustration of voters who feel left behind or negatively impacted by the rapid expansion of these data infrastructures.

All podcast names and trademarks are the property of their respective owners. Podcasts listed on Podtastic are publicly available shows distributed via RSS. Podtastic does not endorse nor is endorsed by any podcast or podcast creator listed in this directory.