Nostalgia & Now
Kelli Williams
168. Late In Life Lesbian
In this candid episode of Nostalgia & Now, host Kelly Williams opens up about her personal journey of self-discovery and coming out later in life. Reflecting on her youth, she discusses the confusion of misinterpreting genuine attractions as mere girl crushes and the years she spent attempting to force herself into relationships with men to conform to expectations. Kelly shares the emotional toll of suppressing her identity while growing up in a conservative environment and explains how she initially identified as bisexual to soften the transition before eventually embracing her true identity as a lesbian. The episode navigates the various stages of her coming out process, from early, tentative conversations with friends and family to the profound relief of finally living authentically after moving to New York. She explores the complex dynamics of family reactions, the internal struggle with the labels assigned to her, and the lessons learned from past romantic experiences. Through this vulnerable reflection, Kelly encourages listeners who may be struggling with their own identities to be patient with themselves, offering a heartfelt reminder that it is never too late to find personal freedom and happiness.
Updated Jul 5, 2026
About This Episode
This week Kelli is sharing her full coming out story!
www.patreon.com/NostalgiaandNowPod
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Listen to Nostalgia & Now in Podtastic
For listeners, not advertisers
More Episodes
170. [BONUS] The Taylor & Travis Wedding
In this bonus episode of Nostalgia & Now, host Kelly Williams shares her candid reflections on the high-profile wedding of Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce. Moving away from her former status as a dedicated superfan, Williams analyzes the event not just as a marriage, but as a carefully calculated business spectacle. She explores the choice of Madison Square Garden as a venue, arguing that despite claims of wanting privacy, the couple opted for a location that practically ensured global attention and public discourse. Williams discusses the diverse and eclectic guest list, weighing in on the presence of various celebrities and the logistical impact the wedding had on local small businesses in New York City. Throughout the episode, she contrasts her past personal connection to Swift’s music with her current perspective on the artist’s evolution into a global brand. Touching on themes of celebrity culture, the couple’s public image, and the intense fan scrutiny that follows their every move, Williams invites listeners to consider whether the wedding was a genuine celebration or a carefully curated event designed to further solidify the couple’s status in the cultural zeitgeist.
169. Devyn Simone on The Challenge, Matchmaking, & More!
In this episode of Nostalgia & Now, host Kelly Williams sits down with television personality, matchmaker, and former Challenge finalist Devyn Simone. The conversation offers an intimate look at Simone’s career, beginning with her memorable tenure on The Real World: Brooklyn and her evolution into a reality television staple. Simone reflects on her time competing on The Challenge, particularly the profound emotional impact of the Free Agents final, which she describes as a turning point that taught her to trust her own resilience. The pair discusses the challenges of being portrayed through reality TV archetypes and the importance of maintaining authenticity, even under the pressure of production narratives. Beyond her television career, Simone shares insights from her work as a matchmaker. She explains how her fascination with relationship psychology and human connection led to her role as a professional dating expert. Simone addresses the modern dating landscape, arguing that while apps can be frustrating, they ultimately offer more opportunities for people to find partners who truly align with their values. She emphasizes the importance of intentionality and personal growth in fostering healthy, modern relationships.
[PATREON PREVIEW] Industry Plant 101 with Lorde
In this episode of Nostalgia & Now, the host dives into the complex and often misunderstood concept of the industry plant. Moving beyond the common assumption that the term implies a lack of talent, the host argues that being an industry plant is more about strategic promotion and the machinery behind a curated career. The discussion explores how the modern music landscape has shifted, particularly with the influence of TikTok, where the pressure to create short, viral-friendly clips often comes at the expense of traditional songwriting and storytelling. Using Lorde as a primary case study, the host examines an article suggesting that the artist’s early career had elements of industry maneuvering designed to legitimize platforms like Spotify. The episode further analyzes how figures like Harry Styles fit into the industry's desire to fill specific archetypes, such as the solo pop boy, to fill gaps in the market. By comparing these experiences to historical industry tactics used for stars like Britney Spears, the host provides a nuanced look at how artists are positioned, packaged, and promoted to achieve longevity in the contemporary entertainment world.
167. Aviv Bruno: The Challenge Comeback Queen
In this episode of Nostalgia and Now, the host sits down with Aviv, a standout competitor known for her impressive comeback story on The Challenge. Aviv opens up about her unexpected return to the franchise, noting that the opportunity arrived at a pivotal moment when she was ready to move on from a corporate career. Despite initial skepticism about her ability to compete against younger contestants, Aviv reflects on the empowering experience of testing her limits in her forties and finding that her athletic capabilities remained stronger than ever. The conversation covers her early days on the show, how she navigated the transition from being a pre-med student to a reality television contestant, and the unique bond she formed with her long-time partner, Darrell. Aviv discusses the evolution of the show, noting that the environment feels more intense, produced, and isolating than it did two decades ago. Throughout the interview, she shares insights on maintaining a grounded perspective, effectively navigating social media scrutiny, and using her life experiences to stay focused on what she can control, ultimately proving that she still has what it takes to compete at the highest level.
166. Celebrity News, Nostalgia, & More With Anna Rumer
In this episode of Nostalgia & Now, the host welcomes journalist and pop culture expert Anna Rumer for a candid conversation about her career, the evolution of media, and their shared passion for reality television. The two reflect on their unlikely friendship, which began during a chance encounter at a celebrity event, and dive into a nostalgic rapid-fire segment covering everything from MySpace and Blackberry culture to the iconic debate between Britney Spears and Christina Aguilera. Rumer shares insights into her decade-long journey in entertainment journalism, detailing the transition from the fast-paced, heavy world of hard news to the lighter, yet equally rigorous, field of pop culture. She discusses the challenges of reporting in the social media era, where audience expectations for speed often clash with traditional journalistic standards. The pair also touches on Rumer’s memorable experience filming for the reality series Deadliest Catch, highlighting the unpredictability of working in the industry. Throughout the discussion, Rumer emphasizes the importance of consistency for aspiring creators and shares her approach to managing the nerves that come with interviewing high-profile celebrities.
165. Songs About Celebs: Amy Winehouse, Mariah Carey, Carly Simon, & More!
In this episode of Nostalgia & Now, host Kelly Williams explores the fascinating world of songs written by celebrities about other celebrities. Moving beyond simple gossip, the episode examines how artists channel personal experiences, frustrations, and disappointments into iconic pop culture moments. The discussion begins with Amy Winehouse’s Me and Mr. Jones, revealing that the track was inspired by her genuine disappointment when rapper Nas missed her birthday party. The host highlights how Winehouse transformed a mundane social letdown into a piece of universal songwriting. The episode then shifts to the legendary feud between Mariah Carey and Eminem, centered on the release of Carey’s hit Obsessed. Williams analyzes how Carey’s witty response and memorable music video effectively controlled the narrative, cementing her status as a pop culture icon. Finally, the podcast revisits Carly Simon’s You’re So Vain, detailing the decades-long mystery surrounding the song’s subject. Williams discusses how Simon turned the track into an interactive puzzle, masterfully using it to critique ego itself. Through these stories, the episode offers an engaging look at how artists use their craft to document, interpret, and sometimes settle scores within the public eye.
164. What's on Kelli's Mind: Aneesa & Travis Kelce, Hilarie & Sophia, Jensen McRae, and The Summer I Turned Pretty
In this bonus episode of Nostalgia & Now, the host dives into a collection of pop culture topics that have been occupying her thoughts. The conversation begins with a look at the recent controversy surrounding the filming of The Summer I Turned Pretty in Plymouth, Massachusetts. The host shares her perspective on the backlash against fans gathering on public streets, arguing that observing film shoots is a long-standing tradition that should remain accessible to the public. Next, the host shares her enthusiasm for singer-songwriter Jensen McRae, comparing her lyrical depth to iconic artists like Sarah Bareilles and Michelle Branch while recommending her track Massachusetts. The episode then pivots to a viral revelation from The Challenge star Aneesa, who recently claimed a past encounter with Travis Kelce. The host breaks down the details of this story, contextualizing it with Kelce’s history of reality television appearances. Finally, the host addresses the unfolding personal rift between One Tree Hill stars Hilarie Burton and Sophia Bush, reflecting on their past work together and the ongoing fan discourse surrounding their friendship.
163. You Know Mall? With Shannon McNamara
In this episode of Nostalgia & Now, host Kelly Williams welcomes Shannon McNamara, host of Fluently Forward, for a deep dive into the cultural phenomenon of mall culture. The conversation serves as a trip down memory lane, exploring how shopping centers functioned as the ultimate "third space" for teenagers in the early 2000s. The pair discusses the mall not merely as a place to shop, but as a hub for socializing, people-watching, and attempting to meet boys. They reminisce about iconic stores like Wet Seal, Charlotte Russe, and the distinct, sometimes overwhelming atmosphere of Abercrombie & Fitch and Hollister. The hosts share personal anecdotes, from hiding contraband in piggy banks to the unique obsession with store-specific scents and the transition into beauty through Bath & Body Works. Beyond the retail therapy, they reflect on the evolving standards of fashion, the "business casual" trends that seemed appropriate for teens at the time, and the strange, nostalgic grip that mall brands still hold today. Through humor and reflection, they capture the specific blend of independence and anxiety that defined coming of age in an era before constant digital connectivity.
162. My Plan To Save MTV
In this episode of Nostalgia & Now, host Kelly Williams shares her passionate blueprint for saving MTV. Despite the decline of traditional cable, Williams argues that MTV possesses an invaluable library of intellectual property that is currently being mismanaged and scattered across clunky, user-unfriendly streaming platforms. She advocates for the creation of a dedicated, streamlined MTV streaming app that would consolidate the network's vast history, including complete catalogs of shows like The Real World, Room Raiders, and TRL. Throughout the discussion, Williams explores the concept of modernizing the network by revamping specific formats. She suggests bringing back Road Rules as a challenge-based alternative to the current reality landscape, while also highlighting the potential for a nostalgic cable block that returns to the network’s roots with music videos and curated retro programming. By focusing on high-quality, accessible content—ranging from the return of music-centric shows like Making the Video to revitalized docuseries like True Life—Williams believes the network could recapture the cultural influence it once held. Ultimately, the episode serves as a love letter to pop culture history and a critique of how legacy media handles its classic assets.
161. Summer House Reunion (Part 3) With Tom Hamlett
In this episode of Nostalgia & Now, the host is joined by guest Tom Hamlett to break down the highly anticipated third part of the Summer House reunion. The conversation dives deep into the messy dynamics of the cast, specifically focusing on the controversial relationship between Amanda and West. The two discuss the complicated timeline of the pair’s romance, exploring whether their connection was an emotional affair that had been brewing for much longer than they admit. Beyond the core love triangle, the hosts analyze the broader fallout within the friend group, touching on the shifting loyalties and the emotional toll the season has taken on members like Jesse Solomon. The episode also highlights the role of reality television production, critiquing how certain segments—such as the recent conflicts and social dynamics—were handled during the reunion taping. The discussion captures the frustration of long-time fans who feel the group's authenticity is fracturing, while also managing to weave in lighthearted critiques of other Bravo personalities and the absurdity of fame within the reality TV bubble. It is a candid, unfiltered look at the state of Summer House.
Related Podcasts
All podcast names and trademarks are the property of their respective owners. Podcasts listed on Podtastic are publicly available shows distributed via RSS. Podtastic does not endorse nor is endorsed by any podcast or podcast creator listed in this directory.