What is making us happy

It can be Dclosed about Disclosure Day. Rit finds Steven Spielberg back in blockbuster Aliens Among a sci fi thriller Territory, a genre he helped create with close encounters, and it feels like a spiritual companion to that nineteen seventy seven masterpiece. Just like that movie, our heroes are humans who are feeling compelled by something they don't understand, and they come up against a lot of authority figures trying to keep a huge secret from the public I'm Aishia Harris. And I'm Genn Weldon, joining us in NPR's pop culture, Happy Hour is the co host of NPR's daily Economics podcast The Indicator Planet Money, Wayon Wong, Hey Wayan. I come in peace. And also joining us is Jaredt Hill. He's the co author of the book Historically Black phrases Hey Jaredt. Hey there, I also come in peace. Very cool. I'm glad we're all peaceful. So in Disclosure today, Josh O'Connor is Daniel, a computer expert who's stolen something from his employer, a sinister shadow organization led by NoOA. He's played by Colin Furth You can tell he's evil because he's trying to kill Daniel, but also his management style is really toxic. Emily Blunt plays Margaret, who does the weather at a Kansas City television station. She suddenly starts to experience strange abilities, along with a mysterious compulsion to find Daniel and help him Guiding both Daniel and Margaret is Hugo. who knows more about what's going on than either of them, he's played by the great and good Coleman Domingo. Disclosure Day is in theaters now. Waylland disclosed to me. What dod you think of Disclosure Day? You know, I mostly liked this movie, but I had to kind of like split my mind into two pieces. Because I think the film you could also think of in two different ways. like one is just as a kind of sci fi thriller, paranoid kind of chase movie which is a lot of like the first part of it. that I really enjoyed, especially as an Xfiles obsessive from back in the day. I really likek that. and it's a Spielberg movie. So it's gonna be well paced, well shot, well lit, all the things. It's gonna be like technically superb But then there's this other track you can analyze the movie on whiches thematic emotional stuff That I was not sinking with Spielberg on this one Often I do It's important to kind of set expectations. And for me, this was not a Spielberg movie where he says something with a capital S that's successful. But it does work from kind of just a purely like propulsive entertaining iece of film with like all the thriller aspects of it. Okay, so summer blockbuster, but maybe not the emotional heftty we're looking for. Yeah. Okay. How about you, Jaret, what do you think? Glen, I don't appreciate your recap of Wayland because that's about what I was gonna say. It's like very big blockbustery movie with, you know, cars driving through walls and you know, it was fun in that way. I'm grateful to hear I wasn't the only one that didn't fully get it. There were parts of it that I thought were really fun and interesting or Oh, maybe you're saying something that I would be fascinated by here. but like other than that, I was like, I don't know exactly when this could have been set for some of the things that they choose to do, the news pieces of it, as a person who worked in local news on air and in production I was trying to understand what world are we living in here? Like there were some parts of that that were really challenging for me as well. Okay. I get what you're saying about that. How about you, Aisha? Where did you come down on this? I mean, I can sense that Spielberg and David Kupp, his screenwriter here are trying to wrestle with our current social political turmoil through This oldpielbererg in. way of what is out there and like what do we want to know and what can we know? And I found a lot of that very compelling, and I think there are moments that really click here, especially when he gets into the realm of like what is this idea of the concept and practice of empathy and how much we extend to other people and what that means. The first third of this movie, if you go into it knowing absolutely nothing, especially if you haven't seen any of the trailers, I think It's fun and exciting to be like, whereere are we going here? because it kind of zigs and then it zags and then it kind of doles out ideas piecemeal. But then once we get to, oh, this is what Spielberg and Kapper are trying to say, it becomes very obvious and even little mushy and Corny for even Spielberg in some places where the emotional heft felt old timey in a way that I don't think quite melds together well with what I think this moment is that we are currently living in. I also just think there wass a lot of things about the execution of the storytelling that just didn't quite become clear to me. I was confused as to why certain characters acted the way they were, what we were supposed to get from those things So all of that to say, I still had a really fun time at the movies. I love hearing John Williams score just pop up especially during an action sequence. and I'm just like, oh, yeah, this is they don't make movies like this anymore. Likeound it sounds like my childhood. Overall, this just doesn't feel like a Spielberg movie that I will necessarily return to anytime soon. Huh. Okay. It's so fascinating you guys are talking about the blockbuster aspects of it as hitting more than the emotional stuff. I'm kind of not feeling the blockbuster aspects here. The thing about a Spielberg sci fi film is that there's always some right? It's a moment that after the movie's over, it's indelible, right? It's a moment that becomes the movie in your head. You got the kid getting abducted in close encounters. You got the moon, like the bike across the moon and ET Creep be drones in Minority report and those the tentacle in the War of the World, I still think about that This movie mostly evaporated for me on the way home. I guess there is a train meets car sequence that I guess it's gonna to stick with I just haven't seen the physics of that before. and I was like, oh, that's how that would play out. That's interesting But I was struck again and again by how much work in this film is left for the dialogue to do in the script. That felt unusual to me in a Spielberg film because he's always counted on his imagery to do the heavy lifting. I will say you are dropped into this movie, as you mentioned, in Media Rz, you don't know what the hell iss going on. one point very early on a character says to another Well, was he an experiencer because you can't dive on them and you're like, what the hell is that? I have that in my notes. What is an experiencer? and they never Yes. I don't know if they ever explain it either.. They kind of do, but here's the thing, if you're confused by those first opening ten, fifteen minutes, just hang on because my man, Coleman Domingo is eventually going to show up to download an entire PDF of exposition Well wearing an earpiece. That's how you know he's official. Exact, so you know, right? And he does it so well because he's calleda Domingo, he cannot. But it's not stuff we need. It's stuff that we could have gotten Without it. do you feel me there? D you s of getting it No, not exactly. o. I will agree with you on a couple of things though, Glenn here. I wrote down in my notes car train hyphen suspension of disbelief because come on. Yeah there's like And I mean, I believe we see it in the trailer, but like the thing that they're doing with this train and this car, I was like, I I don't know how I'm supposed to be buying this is happening The ways that they accomplish a lot of things in this film, I don't understand, there's a moment of a reveal of like, why I'm doing this, right? And I was like, that was it. Like I didn't care. I didn't like I didn't feel invested because of the things that they were demonstrating for me. I'm sort of with you here, but I'm kind of on both sides of it. Okay. There's a moment where the Joshu'Connor character has to sneak across a field Yesull v. That was weird sneaking. was I was like, don't sneak towards the people. you sneak away from the people. What are we doing? Well but that's kind of the point, right? Be I know That's what I mean about like the first, I don't know, third or maybe even half of this movie feeling very strange and again, you don't understand why these characters do And to me, that's exciting at first because feels kind of like an anti mainstream type of movie in that way where it's like we' we're not going to explain everything. But it does seem like once we get into okay, this is what we're trying to be about. and then it winds up trying to be about different things that don't all really coalesce into something I thought that worked. So we have Jane, right, who is Daniel's partner who's played by Eve Hwston. And we learn early on that she used to be a nun and she still has a connection to that world. and she enters with the religious component of this film, the religious themes. She kind of is supposed to carry all of that weight of the religious themes. And then other characters carry the weight of issues with parents or like trauma with their childhood and then there's the truth. There's the psychological thriller paranoia thriller aspect of it. But the Jane character I found interesting because the whole point is that like they're trying to repress this information. And I love this idea of truth in an age where we can trust nothing, especially AI and all of that stuff. And to put that against religion and also like what does that mean likeike then it just kind of fizzles out and doesn't really explore any of those ideas. And I just think that Spielberg, I would think would have a little bit more to say about that than what I think he says here. Yeah, I think that the discussions of fa versus, oh, what would knowing that we're not alone do to people's faith? I think it was a little ham fested like this Jane character give some speeches that I thought were a little bit too speechy for me. I was not as engaged with that aspect of the film mostly because I didn't feel like it added up to anything kind of cohesive or interesting or new. And in some ways it felt kindind of simplistic to me. know, Spielberg has been obsessed with aliens for a really long time, right? So if you take this film in conversation with his earlier films, you want it to present like you maybe cohesive thesis or something of like, how is he feeling about aliens in this stage of his life, right? And it's like also impossible to escape the met narrative around Spielberg that he's getting older. So with each film, you're like, is this his last one? Is this his like final statement about like everything that matters to humanity? o Oh my Godd, it's like all too much But it's like if you think about ET being, you know, like what happens to kids when they encounter aliens and War of the World is kind of like the ultimate nightmare version of that. Like what if the whole planet encounters aliens, it goes really poorly. Then you're like, what is this? And I'm like, I guess this is what happens when elder millennials interact with aliens. I mean, I'm an elder millennial myself and like the Emily Blunt character, I am a daffy lady who does the news. So in some ways, I should have been like really hooked into what this movie was saying I just wasn't sure that there was enough new ideas here in terms of like how do we feel about there being intelligent life elsewhere. That is curious about us too. Didn't feel like there was breaking any new ground, you know? There's an allusion to the aliens being like of supreme being nature And I'm sure that's like the best collection of words to say that. But like the way they said it, I was like Wa I definitely say Supreme being, that's for sure. David Kepman have done it better. Yeah. Well, I remember thinking to myself like, if I were at home, I definitely would have rewound to rehear what they just said ' what do we get here? Like what are we talking about? I feel like I spend a lot of time thinking about God and religion coming out of Divinity school in the last year. and like I'm always interrogating these themes for myself as I've like left Christianity here recently I'm engaging religion in a lot of different kinds of ways. And so when I saw this theme happening in the film, I was like, oh, this is interesting. But like I never really made any other notes past like Supreme beings, God question mark kind of thing.ike, what are we doing here? I think that speaks to kind of a weakness in the film for sure, because you are someone who is like really open and receptive and wants to engage with these things And it's like this like misconnection, right? So then I'm wondering for people who are going to go in maybe more skeptical about those kinds of aspects. This is like really not going like do anything for them. Oh hi, that's me. Yeah. And that's what the script goes out of its way to attempt to do. It is Jane, the Eve Houston character, his girlfriend, Daniel's girlfriend, who questions, you know whether or not Daniel should release this information to the world because she says, we've been raised to believe in a supreme being, and now you're saying that they are the other supreme beings and it's like, whoa, that's not. who said exactly to your point, Jared? Nobody said anything about these. They're just different. They're not necessarily supreme. So I don't know why she'd make that leap. And while I'm wondering why she makes that leap, she consults a nun. The nun explains to her Oh, no, we'll put this in this box and everything's fine. That's what I mean about this movie being over explained a lot and giving us too much information so that this thing which is Spielberg, which is a sense of wonder and awe, that just kind of keeps getting shut down. And speaking of getting shut down, like the Colin Furth character, Noah, who runs this evil organization He should on paper, he is a villain for the ages. He's doing a lot of nasty things. He's trying to kill Daniel But when he gets this big confrontation with Hugo That scene because again, of overwriting, it plays out like he's getting a performance review Hugo keeps complaining that, well, you've been a bad boss and you're dismissive of ideas from the team. and that's like It's not Villain f. That's a bad HR meeting. I do remember thinking like you're telling him he's being a bad manager, but he's like trying to kill people and hide secrets and chasing people through woods. You said it better than I did. But also you're not nice. It's like I don't understand what we're talking about, right? Like I don't understand what's happen could stand to process feedback better. Well, that's sort of the the sort of gloss that's over this this sort of I think it's a generational thing here, maybe, where there's this idea of, you know, the C Firth character and all these other quote unquote bad guys, bad people who are in this movie who were doing We're supposed to be rooting against them, but the film eventually does also ask us to have empathy for them in ways that reveal themselves as the plot goes on And meanwhile, have we even mentioned that apparently World War three is also supposed to be happening at the same time that this is happening? And that just kind of like simmers in the background, but doesn't really present itself. Like I kept forgetting that it was even supposed to be happening, except for like at one point, there's a scene where people are clearly in disaster preparation mode and they're rushing that's another thing that kind of I realiz when watching this movie and went I had to look back and kind of glance at Spielberg's filmography But I really said like Almost all of his films take place either in the past or the future. Rarely do they doeses he make a movie that's like relatively contemporary to the time that it comes out, right? Like some exceptions might be something like GT, Jurassic Park, close encounters This movie is like, you don't, I think Jared's already kind of mentioned this, but like you don't really get into is this supposed to be the present day because the way that things play out, Rigion, yes, that is one aspect of it. That is something that some people would obviously be you know, if alien life was revealed, it would shatter their whole world. But like Does that apply to most of the world? Why is this the secret that is the thing that is just like, o, we can't tell people they can't handle this truth? I guess I just couldn't fully buy into that being such a bombshell, Would our worlds really be shattered? I don't know if mine would really be shattered. I would also offer like As a person who has been a local news reporter, as a person who worked in production in local news, as a person who was like a newspaper journalist in eleventh grade, right? I count those years, mind you. You should. You totally should. Right? Like I'm thinking about the fact that I've been on social media for twenty years Right? likeike twenty years I have I worked in local news in ways over the years and like I'm like, I don't even think those jobs exist anymore in some of the roles that I had, right? And so the idea that we're going to local news, that is like a big broadcast television moment, also makes it feel a little dated to me. And so I'm like, when is this? what are we talking about? Yeah. Yeah, that all kind of feeds into this feeling that I had that a little dated, it's a little old fashioned. and I don't begrudge ber feeling because he' like this elder statesman and I love him and I love his films. And so it's like I don't really begrudge him going to this well, but it just was not resonating with me as a person like living in twenty twenty six, you know what I mean? And like it's not just that this idea of the news being the perfect vehicle to kind of spread this information that feels old fashioned. But even the very sentiment that like We just need to have empathy and then like aliens will teach us what it means to be human and what it means to relate to each other and stuff. like all of that feels a little overly earnest for me for my current mental state. I just, you know, my twenty twenty six brain cannot really accept these earnest feelings that Spielberg is giving me. It also kind of connects me to this other conversation a friend of mine has been having with He is always talking about aliens and he's like I think we have to stop thinking about aliens looking like some version of humans. We anthropomorphize aliens to give them heads and eyes and arms and legs like we have. And he's like, I don't think we would even know what an alien looked like. And I was like, Right Say more And he was like, well, you know, I think this plant be alien How would you know? He's like, your iPhone could be an alien. How would you know? He's like, Beyonce could be an alien. You don't know. And I was like, now hold on now. An alien superstar as it work. R St into something there, right? Well she is a supreme being. Now if they had started there with the supreme being conversation, I would have got it. R? It it like I'm all in forice I was also thinking about like the various different ways we could have seen an alien, right or what that might have looked like, or how that could have actually said something more about the message of Supreme beings or about empathy or about the Times or any of those things. Yeah. You could argue that like arrival did that more effectively with how the aliens were rendered, like that was really interesting and new, right? Yeah Yeah So are we coming down with This is Lesser Spielberg, but it's still Spielberg. So what would you tell people? Are you gonna tell people to go out to the movies this weekend? I think so. Yeah. I mean, here's the thing, Emily Blunt her butt off likeike Oh she's so good. She's really good. Look, I also love Josh O'Connor. I think he's great in everything I've seen him in. honestly, like there's no. bad performances here and that to me is kind of what kept me at all invested once we got past the first third of this movie, I think people should see it. I'm trying to think of the last Sielberg movie where I was like, I'm upset I saw that. It probably would have been ready Player One. This is not that movie. This is far less cynical, far less I think in a way. and for all of my cynicism and my feelings that this is a little too sweet and a little too mushy, I still had a really good time. So I would absolutely suggest it. I'm with you. like even Mor Spielberg so great to watch. And then you're like, again, we're not going to get many more Spielberg movies, right? So like He's gonna make a movie. I'm gonna see it. It's gonna be great. It's gonna be great on just like a visceral level. I was entertained. All right, if I can sum up, you know, this is Lesser Spielberg, but I mean, you know, Lesser Spielberg is still Spielberg Coming up What is making us happy this week Now it is time for our favorite segment of this week and every week. What is making us happy this week? Waylon kick us off. What's making you happy this week? Well, I am pre gaming for the Odyssey and I could not be more excited about this movie. So in terms of my preparation for the Odyssey, I decided to reread the Odyssey, which I hadn't read since high school when it was assigned. So I picked up the Emily Wilson translation a translation that came out in twenty seventeen and it was the first translation into English by a woman. So that's kind of the hoopla around it, but I H such a great time reading the Odyssey in this translation It just clocks a lot. You're like, wow, you're like everything's so exciting. parts of it are funny. partarts of it are so violent that now I'm actually a little scared for the movie. I think I'm gonna have my high school This is just too violent for me. There's so many little clever bits and she uses like Itst pretty modern language, but it doesn't feel like try hard modern language. And I just devour this. So what's making me happy is the Odyssey, the Emily Wilson translation. Thank you very much, Wayon, that's a great pick. and I'm gonna need to do some homework too, I think. Yes. Thankk you very much. Jarered, what is making you happy this week, sir? Well,, as you were asking us whether or not we should have saw this movie, I was thinking about a show that I listened to called Seated, The Blackest Show aboutout moovies, who was hosted by one of our friends, Traayal Anderson And Ray Lo Jir. and they always wrate movies by whether you should be seated in a theater, whether you should stream it at home or whether you should skip it And I thought to myself like, I could have streamed it, right with this film. And so I really enjoy the conversations that they have. They're covering all kinds of different films just from a black perspective. And obviously, Trevll and I hosted a podcast together. We've written a book together. we know each other quite well, but I've enjoyed seeing them in this format because Trevvel is a film critic at heart. They're covering all of these different films and many of them are films I've never seen or wouldn't see otherwise. but for the folks that are out there that really enjoy a film podcast, Id tell you to go check out S it. Thank you so much, Jaredo. suubscribe And done, thank you very much. Aisha, what is making you happy this week? Have I mentioned on the show before that I am a millennial? Yes. I I might have come up wait what? What The devil you're saying I know, I re like a G zZ. What is making me happy this week is Rob Anderson, Are you afraid of the nineties Rob Anderson is a very, very Uber millennial comedian, his latest stand up special It's so enjoyable. It is this spirited tour through the chaotic, shambolic and quite conservative pop culture of the nineteen nineties. It's like this l fi, yet, I would describe as like very precisely rendered presentation, complete with clips, animations, musical numbers, some very inspired costume changes inspired by certain things Samantha American Girl doll or the Princess Diana commemorative Beanie baby, which I did own when I was a child. But yeah, it's just very enjoyable. He is using truly unhinged cultural references to jump off and observe about how the nineties sort of tackled all of these hot button social issues queerness, drugs, race, all those things. So if you were like me and you were veryer, very heavily millennial coded or just fully millennial. I think you'll enjoy Rob Anderson's Are You Afraid of the nineties and it's streaming on YouTube. Excellent, thank you very much. just for the jumpsuits alone. I think it's. Thank you so much All right, what's making me happy? Kylie is a three part documentary about the life and loves and career of the great Australian pop singer Kylie Minogue on Netflix I thought we werere going to say Klie Jenner.. I would watch that documentary too, but this also Now it is Kylie Minogue. No, yes. It was made with her full participation. and no, it does not like to be three episodes long. And it's also weird how much it's devoted to her love life, But in the documentaries's defense, she keeps dating lot of very hot models and actors and musicians. I mean she Javed Lenny Krabbz and Michael Hutchins of NXcess. and both of those men are what happens if you pour raw sex into a pair of leather pants. So you know I'm in It also spends a lot of time highlighting just how poorly she's been treated by critics over the years, which at first seems self indulgent, but then you get some clips of these dudes being crazily sexist and dismissive in this kind of boring rock pureist way She gets the last word on them. She also worked with Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds. and Nick Cave, I love Nick Cave. He's just a delight every time he's on screen. It's a very flawed documentary. Especially for Americans who still don't seem to get What the rest of the world gets about Kylie Minogue. It's worth checking out the documentary Kylie On Netflix and that is what is making me happy this week And that brings us to the end of our show Willon Wong Jareredt Hill, Aisha Harris. Thank you so much for being here. Thank you. Thank you. This episode was produced by Liz Metzker, Hfs Safaima, and Mike Katz have been edited by our showrunner, Jessica Ritia, Hellokermin provides our theme music. Thank you for listening to Pop Culture Happy Hour from NPR. I'm Len Weldon, and we'll see you all next week