The Oesterreich Murder: Secrets in the Attic

The Missing Candy Heiress and the Chicago Horse Mafia

Jun 29, 202634 minSummary

In this episode of Serial Killers, the host explores the baffling disappearance of Helen Brach, a multimillionaire candy heiress who vanished in 1977. What begins as a seemingly routine missing persons case quickly spirals into a dark web of deception, forged documents, and potential foul play. The investigation centers on two primary figures: Helen’s mysterious houseman, Jack Matlick, and her associate Richard Bailey, a man known for his history of defrauding wealthy widows. The hosts delve into the suspicious circumstances surrounding Helen’s final days, including her sudden departure from the Mayo Clinic and the strange behavior of those in her inner circle. The episode uncovers the existence of the Chicago Horse Mafia, a corrupt ring of con artists that used high-stakes equestrian investments to swindle vulnerable victims. Through witness testimonies and legal records, the podcast pieces together a disturbing theory that Helen may have been targeted after threatening to expose this syndicate. Despite subsequent confessions and decades of investigation, the case remains officially unsolved, leaving behind a chilling mystery defined by greed, betrayal, and the elusive nature of truth.

Murder on the Galapagos? Island Utopia Spirals into Death and Disappearances

Jun 22, 202639 minSummary

In this episode of Serial Killers, the hosts delve into the dark and mysterious history of Floreana, a remote island in the Galapagos that became the site of a failed utopian experiment in the 1930s. The story begins with Dr. Friedrich Ritter and his partner, Dore Strauch, who sought to escape modern societal pressures by living in complete, tranquil isolation. However, their dream of a naturalist paradise quickly unraveled as they struggled with the physical demands of island life and the scrutiny of international tabloids, which attracted unwanted attention to their remote sanctuary. The situation grew increasingly complex and volatile with the arrival of other settlers, including the Whitmer family and the self-proclaimed Baroness Eloise von Wagner-Bosquet. What began as a quest for peace descended into a claustrophobic power struggle defined by ego, shifting alliances, and sudden disappearances. The episode explores the harrowing events that followed, including a brutal drought, suspicious deaths, and claims of murder that remain unsolved to this day. Ultimately, the hosts use this chilling case to reflect on the futility of escaping human conflict, suggesting that isolation often magnifies the very problems people attempt to leave behind.

The Molly Watson Case: Bride-to-Be Murdered Right Before Her Wedding

Jun 8, 202632 minSummary

In this episode of Serial Killers, the host examines the tragic murder of Molly Watson, a bride-to-be who was killed just days before her wedding in 2018. The narrative details Molly’s relationship with James Addie, a man she met while working at a correctional facility. While Molly believed she was planning a future with her fiancé, Addie was secretly leading a double life. He was already married to another woman, Melanie, and had spun an elaborate web of lies—including faking a car accident and the death of his wife—to keep his two worlds separate. The episode explores how Addie’s lies began to unravel when Molly became suspicious and started searching for proof of his claims. Key insights include the investigative breakthroughs made by local authorities, such as the discovery of a discarded, misprinted t-shirt that Addie’s own daughter identified, and the revelation of burner phones used to maintain his deception. Ultimately, the hosts discuss how the collision of Addie’s two lives led to a calculated act of violence. The episode serves as a chilling case study on the dangers of profound dishonesty and the devastating consequences of a secret life.

Heaven's Gate: Rehearsing for the Apocalypse

Jun 1, 202639 minSummary

This episode of Serial Killers examines the origins and tragic progression of the Heaven’s Gate cult, led by Marshall Applewhite and Bonnie Nettles. The hosts explore how two individuals, feeling alienated from mainstream society, built a belief system centered on the idea that human bodies were merely temporary vessels. By blending biblical prophecy with science fiction and New Age philosophy, Applewhite and Nettles convinced followers that an extraterrestrial spacecraft would transport them to a higher level of existence if they purged their human desires, including individuality and romantic attachment. The discussion highlights the group's transition from nomadic seekers to a rigid, regimented organization. Through the implementation of strict behavioral codes, androgynous uniforms, and even surgical interventions, members sought to detach from their humanity. The podcast provides an intimate look at the group's quiet, disciplined lifestyle, contrasting their seemingly mundane day-to-day existence with the apocalyptic fanaticism that culminated in the 1997 mass suicide. Ultimately, the hosts reflect on the unsettling realization that the members were not unlike many others: desperate for purpose, connection, and a sense of belonging in an unpredictable world.

The Convict Who Faked His Death For Love

May 25, 202643 minSummary

In this episode of Serial Killers, the host explores the extraordinary life of Steven Russell, a man whose complex search for identity led him into a cycle of deception, romance, and daring escapes. Adopted and raised in a conservative Virginia household, Russell spent decades masking his sexuality before eventually embracing his true self. However, his desire to maintain an affluent lifestyle for his partners led him to criminal activities, including fraud and embezzlement. The narrative delves into his obsessive dedication to his lovers, Jimmy and later Philip Morris, which prompted Russell to execute multiple, increasingly audacious prison escapes. Using elaborate disguises, forged documents, and sheer psychological manipulation, he repeatedly broke out of captivity to reunite with those he loved. The host analyzes the dichotomy between Russell’s brilliant, albeit destructive, improvisational skills and his deep-seated fear of abandonment. Ultimately, the episode examines the psychological cost of his double life, detailing how his desperate attempts to secure a future with his partners resulted in a life sentence in solitary confinement, cementing his legacy as one of the most prolific con artists in American history.

The Trunk Murderess Whose Gruesome Crime Captivated a Nation

May 18, 202632 minSummary

The hosts of Serial Killers delve into the haunting 1931 case of Winnie Ruth Judd, a woman whose life in Phoenix spiraled from a hopeful marriage into one of the most notorious crimes in American history. The episode explores how a web of jealousy, an affair with a prominent local businessman named Happy Jack, and a crumbling friendship with roommates Anne LeRoy and Sammy Samuelson led to a gruesome double homicide. After shooting her two friends, Judd attempted to transport their remains in steamer trunks to Los Angeles, an act that earned her the sensationalized moniker, The Trunk Murderess. The hosts meticulously break down the conflicting narratives surrounding the murders, examining Judd’s shifting claims of self-defense versus later confessions that suggest premeditation. Throughout the discussion, the episode highlights the mystery of whether Judd acted entirely alone or had secret accomplices, as well as the societal fixation on the case during the Prohibition era. Through a careful analysis of evidence, court testimonies, and long-lost letters, the podcast provides a gripping look at a crime fueled by betrayal and the enduring struggle to uncover the truth behind a fractured life.

Meet Your New Host!

For Your Inner Forensic Psychologist: Psychopedia

Darker Than Fiction: Crimehub

A Show With Real Impact: Voices for Justice